Gamasutra: The Art & Business of Making Gamesspacer
View All     RSS
September 23, 2014
arrowPress Releases
September 23, 2014
PR Newswire
View All





If you enjoy reading this site, you might also want to check out these UBM Tech sites:


 
Game Design: Brainstorming, Prototyping, Game Making & Marketing
by Adam Saltsman on 09/15/11 01:08:00 pm   Expert Blogs

The following blog post, unless otherwise noted, was written by a member of Gamasutra’s community.
The thoughts and opinions expressed are those of the writer and not Gamasutra or its parent company.

 

Lately it seems like there is a lot of confusion over the term "game design" and what it means.  I wanted to quickly (headed out the door at the mo, so very quickly!!) explain why I don't include brainstorming or marketing under the game design umbrella.  I may update this in the future based on feedback and further reflection, but in the meantime...

Brainstorming

Brainstorming is the process of coming up with an elaborating on ideas for projects on paper, in digital word documents, or in digital graphics files.  This is the part of a project where we are writing down ideas about rules or doing concept art for what the game might look like.  Brainstorming is not game design.  Brainstorming is fun, but it is wholly speculative and the results are ultimately worthless.  Brainstorming is not game design.

 

Prototyping

Prototyping, in game design, is the ongoing process of exploring and validating ideas in the context of creating a functional and interesting new game.  Prototyping is the point when we can actually understand and see the value of our ideas, and a functional prototype is the first real, extant instance of a game's design in the real world, and a functioning, interesting prototype is in many ways invaluable.  Prototyping is very much game design.

Game Making

Game making is the process of creating a game, and includes prototyping but also polishing.  Polish is the process of fine-tuning and dressing up the result of your prototypes for mass consumption, and is tantamount to marketing in many ways.  However, all those little holistic changes to the game make all the difference in the world.  I don't believe that prototyping is a "phase" done before polish, but a parallel process throughout development.  However, I do believe that many games (most?) should be built on a 30% time spent prototyping, 70% time spent polishing type of relationship.  Game making is game design, and vice versa.

Marketing

The process of taking a game and presenting it to the world for mass consumption.  Marketing, for me, is not part of game design, and I extend this to include many things that are I think counter-intuitive or controversial.  For example, taking the core gameplay from a popular Flash game like Crush the Castle (30m plays!) and changing the graphics and controls is a process that I consider marketing, not game design.  Likewise, taking the core gameplay from a less popular Flash game like Radical Fishing and adding touch controls and changing the graphics is also marketing.  The idea that these adaptations constitute game design in any real sense, or are somehow worthy of praise and encouragement from a design perspective, utterly baffles me.  These are massive marketing achievements, and should be studied and praised as such, but these are not good examples of game design.

My point, in the end, is not to somehow denigrate brainstorming or marketing, but it is important to me that we understand that these things, while related to game design, don't have much to do with the real process of designing games.  Game Design, or as I prefer to call it Game Making, is the process of testing, refining and cross-pollinating our ideas until we have created an interactive system that introduces both sense-pleasure and intellectual engagement.  Neither brainstorming nor marketing has enough to do with these goals to be legimitately considered part of the process in my mind, at this point in my life.


Related Jobs

DoubleDown Interactive
DoubleDown Interactive — Seattle, Washington, United States
[09.23.14]

Principal Game Designer
DoubleDown Interactive
DoubleDown Interactive — Seattle, Washington, United States
[09.23.14]

Senior Product Manager
Cloud Imperium Games
Cloud Imperium Games — Santa Monica, California, United States
[09.23.14]

Marketing Director
Amazon
Amazon — Irvine, California, United States
[09.23.14]

Software Development Manager






Comments


E McNeill
profile image
I sorta get where you're coming from, but this seems like a really strange set of distinctions. Why is wholly speculative brainstorming "ultimately worthless"? What happens if you prototype those ideas and then decide to abandon them; was that an act of game design? I feel like you're arguing both ways.



On the other side, why is it that "exploring and validating ideas" and "dressing up [games] for mass consumption" are aspects of game design, but altering the graphics, controls, and sometimes rules of existing games is not game design? I think you're making a dig at Angry Birds (and there's plenty to complain about there), but they added substantively new mechanics, created more charming graphics and themes, and made the controls easier and more intuitive. How is that just marketing? It seems to me that you'd also have to say that the difference between Dune II and Starcraft II is just marketing, and that seems indefensible.



Why is it that real game design is composed of "exploring and validating" ideas, but not "elaborating" them? "Polish" is game design, but alterations to graphics and controls are not? Why use these definitions?

Prash Nelson-Smythe
profile image
I think the most successful games consider marketing through every stage of the game design process (perhaps not conciously). Part of marketing is understanding your market. The market is your audience. So part of marketing is understanding what your players will want.



Marketing isn't always convincing customers to buy a product that the creator wants to make. It's also convincing the creator to create a product that customers want to buy. Therefore, the very first steps of game design could be influenced by marketing.

Glenn Storm
profile image
"... taking the core gameplay from a popular Flash game ... and changing the graphics and controls is a process that I consider marketing, not game design."



That's a neat way to put it.

John Affleck
profile image
Brainstorming is such a powerful practice to leverage your life! I find it most stimulating and effective to do this online. There are many tools to do this, but I prefer it very simple and easy. http://www.scatterbrain.nl is my tool of choice.


none
 
Comment: