Gamasutra: The Art & Business of Making Gamesspacer
View All     RSS
December 18, 2014
arrowPress Releases
December 18, 2014
PR Newswire
View All
View All     Submit Event






If you enjoy reading this site, you might also want to check out these UBM Tech sites:


 
Lessons Learned from Localizing Canabalt
by Adam Saltsman on 01/17/12 01:28:00 pm   Expert Blogs   Featured Blogs

7 comments Share on Twitter Share on Facebook    RSS

The following blog post, unless otherwise noted, was written by a member of Gamasutra’s community.
The thoughts and opinions expressed are those of the writer and not Gamasutra or its parent company.

 

At the end of 2011 we finally released an update to our popular game Canabalt that had support for something like 15 languages. If only for the sake of our own unreliable memories I wanted to record some of the things we learned during that process. This is not, by any stretch of imagination, a mandate to localize your own software, or, if you decide to, to do it this way. It is simply a public recording of our experience and our plans for the future :)  Much of what is recorded here will have to do with iOS specifically, but likely applies to other platforms as well.



Fan Translations (i.e. Crowdsourced Translations)

We certainly were not the first game to rely on fans to translate the game content into other languages. World of Goo and Fieldrunners, among others, were famously ported to other languages by dedicated fans.  If this was a traditional postmortem, though, we would definitely file "fan translations" under the What Went Right column. We had a ton of up-front interest from fans from all over the world, who in general displayed a remarkable degree of dedication, patience and professionalism.  I believe there were a couple of keys to making this work though:

  1. Canabalt has very little, in the grand scheme of things, to translate. It is maybe 1 page of double-spaced full sentences, if that.
  2. Canabalt is a popular game with some very passionate fans.

The combination of these two things I think led very naturally to some amazing people being willing to dedicate a few hours to "the cause" as it were. The ratio of effort to results was quite good for them I think!



File Management, Nuts & Bolts

The way we did most of the translation work, physically speaking, for Canabalt, I would probably file under the What Went Wrong column, even though it basically worked. We put together a central file in english, clearly annotated, of all the sentences we needed translated. Then we sent a copy of this file to anyone that was interested in working on a particular language. This was really easy to do at the start of the process. It was... less easy to deal with at the end of the process.

Copy-pasting and touching up the translated files at the end of the process was sufficiently daunting that we ended up delaying the inclusion of the translated files for months! It was that boring. In the end we had to kind of pull ourselves together and just knuckle down and do the grunt work, which was about 3 or 4 work days of copying, pasting, and touching up files. More later on why that took so long, but in the meantime, we figured out what we think might be a better approach. We are testing it out on some new languages now, so the jury is still out... but it seems pretty promising.

In the future I'd like to try prepping a Google doc of the annotated English language file, and then duplicating that to any requested language. These other language files will be publicly viewable, possibly publicly exposed using a Google Form. Fans who are up for doing a translation can email us, and we will then add them as a private editor for that Google doc. Once the editors (3 or fewer, ideally) are satisfied with the translation, we can simply copy-paste the entirety of the file directly into the XCode language project file and test it out in-game.



EFIGS and Other Acronyms

Initially it seemed quite important to focus on EFIGS to maximize our effort to "new market exposure" or whatever, which actually makes a lot of sense if you're doing traditional localization, rather than crowd-sourcing. Traditional localization is pay-by-the-word, so there's a kind of obvious, direct cost there. Crowd-sourced localization has muddier, less obvious costs though, which generally boiled down to about 2-4 hours of grunt work per language. This made including some non-standard languages viable and interesting, and allowed us to cater to small but vocal fan-bases in oft-ignored countries like Finland or the Czech Republic.  For a small company with a small game I actually think this makes a lot of sense. Those players mean a lot to us!

It also meant that we were able to survey the impact the different languages had technologically. Languages like Italian and German are infamously lengthy, and thus problematic, especially if you make tight, minimalist games with compressed interfaces!  We found that 1.5-2 lines of English text expanded to nearly 3 lines in Italian or German. However, many emerging markets like China have logographic languages that can easily fit within the English layouts for very little effort (you will, of course, need a font that supports a few extra thousand characters).  For a small developer, those things are worth keeping in mind I think.



Various Pitfalls & Other Details

Finally I wanted to run down some other things we ran into along the way, that we will definitely be keeping in mind for the future:

  1. Text with manual line breaks in it is a huge pain in the butt, and scales badly. Good word wrapping and variable height text display areas are not that hard to do, programmatically, and will vastly simplify the process of localization later in development.
  2. We added special fields in the language file we sent out to translators that we parsed into our Credits screen, so they could add themselves to the game credits. This worked really well, since then each translator is credited but only in their own language, completely automatically. I think we can do it even better in the future though; there was some confusion about whether they should credit themselves as "Translator for Language X" in English or in their native language. Note: all of our translators worked for free - being credited in their native language was the least we could do!
  3. Localizing achievements in iTunes Connect is a horror I wish upon no one, and I have no plans to ever do localized achievements until they provide some better procedural approach. As it stands, as far as I know, you have to translate all the achievement text in your own game, but then upload individual graphics and achievement text to iTunes Connect's web interface manually. This is patently insane. There needs to be a way to upload a translated achievements package that can be generated locally from the game's existing language files. That or we need an unpaid intern.
  4. Canabalt has some sentences that use variables to customize their display. For example, "I ran 400m before falling to my death on my iPhone." uses two different variables to indicate how far the player ran and what device they are using.  Not all languages display the distance measurement before the device name.  The sentence could just as easily be "On my iPhone, I ran 400m before falling to my death."  So when you are using multiple variables within a single translated sentence, make sure you encode the ordering of those variables, especially in C-style languages. Otherwise, players may be disappointed to find that they "ran iPhone meters before falling to their death on their 400."
  5. Text encoding can be a bit of a headache. Usually your IDE will do a good job of opening the file, but if the translator saved it wrong (UTF-8 instead of UTF-16 or some such thing) then it may be possible that you can't get at the proper characters at all, and have to request changes from the translator. I am hopeful that relying more on Google Docs in the future might alleviate some of these issues.
  6. We added a language override selection to Canabalt's options. This was a huge win, for a few reasons: it wasn't that nightmarish to implement, players liked it because they could still play in English even if their phone was Russian, and it made it very easy to test the different languages as we implemented them. We found that some languages (like Bulgarian I think?) could be set up in XCode, but would not automatically trigger using the phone's built-in language settings.



Results

Someone on twitter reminded me that I never mentioned anything about whether this had any impact on sales. As far as I can tell, at least in the short term, the introduction of new language options has had no measurable effect on sales.  I am confident that in the long run it was a good idea though. It broadens our fanbase, if only by a little, and it felt good to deliver fan-generated content to other international fans. Canabalt was more than two years old by the time we released this update as well. Internationalization may matter more at launch, when international app stores may be more likely to feature the game. The time put in to implement was substantial though, and non-English-speaking iPhone users are still a minority of the market.


Related Jobs

Cloud Imperium Games
Cloud Imperium Games — SANTA MONICA, California, United States
[12.17.14]

Senior Producer
Cloud Imperium Games
Cloud Imperium Games — Austin, Texas, United States
[12.17.14]

Associate Producer
Activision Publishing
Activision Publishing — Santa Monica, California, United States
[12.17.14]

Associate Producer-Call of Duty
Remedy Entertainment
Remedy Entertainment — Espoo, Finland
[12.16.14]

QA Tester





Loading Comments

loader image