My Message close
GAME JOBS
Latest Jobs
spacer View All     Post a Job     RSS spacer
 
May 25, 2013
 
Treyarch / Activision
Technical Animator
 
Treyarch / Activision
Game Systems Designer
 
Infinity Ward / Activision
Senior Tools Engineer
 
Airtight Games
Environment Artist
 
App Minis LLC
Senior Unity Game Programmer
 
Gameloft
Game Designer
spacer
Blogs

  Why I Don't Trust Game Designers That Go To The Gym
by Alan Jack on 06/17/11 05:20:00 am
7 comments Share on Twitter Share on Facebook RSS
 
 
The following blog was, unless otherwise noted, independently written by a member of Gamasutra's game development community. The thoughts and opinions expressed here are not necessarily those of Gamasutra or its parent company.

Want to write your own blog post on Gamasutra? It's easy! Click here to get started. Your post could be featured on Gamasutra's home page, right alongside our award-winning articles and news stories.
 

Play_park_slide_img_52081 

When I was little, excercise meant taking our bikes into the forest and reenacting the Death Star trench run from Star Wars (contrary to popular opinion, playing as Porkins was a lot of fun - getting to scream and yell and jump off your bike before it hits a tree ...).  It meant walking for miles along an old railway track, stopping to climb trees or tie rope swings to overhangs or explore little dirt paths.  At the very least, it meant a trip to the park to climb, run, jump - freeform activity with no restrictions, no strict goals, and nothing to clog up our heads as we played and relaxed.

1227361448105_f

Now I'm an adult, and I find myself tethered to a desk for 8 hours a day, my exercise regime has fallen by the wayside.  The concept of the game developer as an overweight, unhealthy nerd is one we need to dispell, and our minds - our most important commodity - require a healthy body to stay healthy in themselves.  Yet the common solution is to go the gym - a dry, dull place in which people pay money to run on the spot, and pedal bikes that go nowhere, all with the same fixed goal of achieveing a perfectly formed body that looks like everyone else's.  We work our pecs, or our delts, or our glutes, all based on a fixed template of human appearance that takes little account of the majesty of human individuality.

This might be a common complaint about the modern world and its cardboard-cut-out population, but where it really hits me hard is that I design games for a living (or, at least, I aspire to - I design games for grades right now).  The reason my exercise is sacrificed, the reason I don't have the time to ride bikes or walk old train tracks is that I'm busy crafting whole worlds full of imaginitive fun and frolics for others.

So when I see game designers "hitting the gym", I have to ask - where is the fun?  Where, in your world, is the emergence you strive to create in fantasy worlds during work hours?  Where, in your life, is the agency you so desperately struggle to create for your game testers?  Where is that sense of purpose, of self-orientated goals, that you so lovingly pour into your games?

Of course I'm aware of the facetious nature of this argument - there's emergence in any exercise, there's self-orientated goals in the number of weight crunches you can do, or the amount of time you can pedal your infernal machines, and there's agency in seeing the change in your physique and feeling the burn in your chest - but these are plain, simple responses.  If this were a game world, you would (I would hope) laud the repetitious nature of your activity, the old-school simplicity of a numerical counter as goal, or the lack of individuality in the nature of your goals.

Overall, attending a gym - to me - smacks of that one aspect of modern life that should be absent from anyone in any creative art: conformity.  The idea that we should be healthy and fit is ideal - a healthy mind can only live on a healthy body, and that can't be maintained with 8 hours a day spent at your desk.  However, I've got more time for a game designer who climbs rocks or mountains, runs up hills, or goes paintballing, or even just runs a few laps around the block, than I do for someone who pays money rides a bike to nowhere.

 
 
Comments

Daniel Silber
profile image
Your criticism is pretty ironic considering our profession.



We spend many hours learning to craft artificial environments, characters and sound effects - and yet for some reason the idea of lifting weights in real life disturbs you?



Being a game developer usually necessitates a lot of hours at the computer, sitting on your ass - and not all developers make the time to take care of their physical selves. So if it is easier to hop onto a treadmill for 15 minutes than go for a run out in the rain, who cares? At least they are exercising.



I hear what you're saying - that there are more interesting ways to get exercise. True dat. I do martial arts - it is way more exciting than the gym. But why would you care how others choose to get their exercise?

Alan Jack
profile image
I'm being facetious for the sake of argument. Based on the fact that I've had more response to this blog post (in other blogs) than any other, I think it worked.



But yeah, it doesn't really matter, except that I'd sort of expect the kind of person that designs games to get bored by things like gyms and dull office buildings and the general mundaneness of regular life.



As for the irony ... what disturbs me is that the worlds we craft sometimes end up being more fun than our own real worlds! Its the subject of Jane McGonigal's Reality Is Broken if you're interested in reading more about it. In truth it goes much further than just the gym - why must our jobs be so mundane? When did we deem "play" as something just for children?

Daniel Silber
profile image
Fair enough. But I would argue that I am creative in part because of the dull and boring parts of my childhood - that my mind would make interesting stories to fill bland stretches. Even as an adult I do much better than the average person during times where no entertainment is available.

John Martins
profile image
The faster you ride you bike through a forest, the more of your concentration goes on the trees... sit on an exercise bike staring at the wall and your mind could be on anything!

Matt Christian
profile image
It's worth noting that being an out of shape, overweight programmer or designer in itself can be considered conformity to the 'techy stereotype'. Sure, it would be incredibly dull to play as someone on a treadmill for an hour by simply pushing a joystick forward for an hour, but my primary goal at the gym isn't to have fun. I definitely enjoy it but it's not 'a game'.



I currently work 40 hours a week (that's 8 hours a day at a desk) and still have time for the gym between 1 and 2 hours a night. Exercise has been proven to relieve stress among loads of other benefits that aren't just being 'fit' so it can almost be considered as returning you part of those 8 hours. It is possible to maintain this schedule.



A designer who exercises outdoors is no better or worse than someone who works out in a controlled atmosphere and giving more credit to one is giving more credit to someone based on their interests. It'd be like me saying I'm a better designer than Joe Schmo because I listen to Rock and he listens to Pop, and pop is total conformity.

Alan Jack
profile image
That's all true. As I've said before, I was being facetious (perhaps very much over-facetious) with my arguing to try and make a bold statement about these things.



Music tastes are an important thing. I often wonder what big-budget games would be like if game developers listened to less thrash/speed metal and more be-bop or jazz - would their creative output follow the tonal shift away from adrenaline and structure to relaxation and improvisation?

Matt Christian
profile image
That'd definitely be an interesting experiment. You never know what little things could change a developer's mood and impact their design or final product.


none
 
Comment:
 




 
UBM Tech