Bart Stewart's Blog
Avid game design theorist; experienced programmer and software project manager; first (noncommercial) game developed was a real-time multiplayer space combat sim for IBM mainframes in 1985. Gaming-related interests include "deep" gameplay, Explorer/Simulationist gameplay, psychology of gamers, player-centered design, massively multiplayer game design, and industry trends. Personal game design blog at: http://flatfingers-theory.blogspot.com/
A month before its release, Watch Dogs is being described as having a highly dynamic world conducive to thoughtful exploration, but also as having simplified mechanics better suited to exciting action. Which impression is more accurate? Both? Neither?
In which we consider how the careful selection of gameplay elements can burn a game into our hearts and minds.
Game developers often try to find and remove all unexpected interactions in the belief that anything not intended is likely to be a bug. But this may be unnecessarily preventing the development of games in which surprise is a necessary feature.
Since Warren Spector demonstrated Epic Mickey at E3 2010, there's been a microburst of gaming media coverage of his design philosophy that "play style matters." It's about time.
At GDC 2010, Blizzard EVP of Game Design Rob Pardo described a number of design concepts behind Blizzard's games. While these are obviously successful for Blizzard's games, they can be seen as working only for simple action games. There are other kinds.
The online reaction to Jesse Schell's DICE 2010 presentation can be understood as a reaction to computer gaming becoming a mass entertainment form. Where early gamers enjoyed intangible immersion, today's typical gamer now expects tangible rewards.
Bart Stewart's Comments
[Blog - 08/16/2014 - 03:18]
I suspect we 're going ...
I suspect we 're going to see more of this style of collaboration. So getting a peek at some experienced opinions regarding what this approach is and is not well-suited for, as well as how it can work in practice, is very helpful. r n r nThanks for publishing this.
[Blog - 08/14/2014 - 04:37]
In late 1990 I was ...
In late 1990 I was playing Wing Commander for many hours after work. As part of my job, I had access to a massive 20-inch NEC 5D monitor. So playing WC was for the time like looking through an actual cockpit window. r n r nOne Friday night, after many ...
[Feature - 12/07/1999 - 12:00]
I recall reading this when ...
I recall reading this when Gamasutra first published it. I 've cited it many times since then it 's still a great read. r n r nThanks for bringing it back
[News - 07/31/2014 - 09:43]
Ten years from now I ...
Ten years from now I expect all the games I play will have names like Mnrglns, Jrqfnrq Kmydkhz, and Arrhglllfief: The Pmglurgling just to avoid having to deal with this kind of nonsense.
[Blog - 07/25/2014 - 03:36]
While I don 't object ...
While I don 't object to studies like these, they give the impression of being narrowly focused on sociopolitical interests: aggression, violent games, stereotyping. r n r n Incidentally, if a group shows a pattern of preference for something, it 's not an erroneous use of a stereotype to conclude ...
[News - 07/30/2014 - 07:05]
I don 't mind paying ...
I don 't mind paying a subscription for something I use frequently every month. Moving to a monthly subscription was a great improvement over hourly charges back in the day of CompuServe, for example. r n r nBut who is going to get that kind of value from any game ...