Gamasutra: The Art & Business of Making Gamesspacer
View All     RSS
October 25, 2014
arrowPress Releases
October 25, 2014
PR Newswire
View All
View All     Submit Event





If you enjoy reading this site, you might also want to check out these UBM Tech sites:


 
Dodging Disillusionment
by Brandon Battersby on 09/07/10 11:11:00 pm   Featured Blogs

The following blog post, unless otherwise noted, was written by a member of Gamasutra’s community.
The thoughts and opinions expressed are those of the writer and not Gamasutra or its parent company.

 

In regards to Fallout 3: There is just so much to do and to go to, a feeling of mystique around every building and area. I loved it. Then the ugly feeling started creeping over me that I had when playing Morrowind and Oblivion. Disillusionment…Dolgion Chuluunbaatar

 

Willing suspension of disbelief is a formula that most writers understand and adhere to when crafting their characters and worlds. In a way, it is a story’s integrity and one of its most grounding characteristics. The idea is that when developing a fictional world, it is important to balance the surreal with enough detail and universal truth to keep the participants (in this case, the gamer) grounded in the experience—whatever that may be.

I wish to highlight some important literary elements in games that help developers achieve this. Keep in mind, this is a topic regarding games that utilize narrative agents and have at least the slightest hint of story implementation.

Understanding what keeps players grounded in a game is simple. Players need something to attach to. This can come in many ways; three I would like to focus on is character, place, and conflict.

Character

Character is, by far, one the most important elements of grounding. The player and player character need to have a relationship; the player needs to see a human being behind those pixels in order to relate and attach to him. Even if your character isn’t technically human,(IE. Playing as a Ninja Turtle) there needs to be strong sense of humanity within him or her. The character needs to express emotion, experience pain and pleasure, and also be the center of the conflict.

This kind of character is relatable to and acts as the sociological bridge into the world—potentially even the sensual bridge, depending on what perspective the game is played in. The new Metroid series, for example, explores the world through a helmet interface that reflects Samus’ pretty eyes. This technique casually reminds the player that there is a person behind the mask, humanizing the unstoppable weapon.

Even if the player character of the game is meant to be mute like Legend of Zelda’s Link or the dude from GTA 3, you can still humanize them with enough detail. Some simple tricks are as followed:

Flawed Characters

Make them flawed. No human being is perfect. Make the characters have unlikeable traits within their personality, appearance, mannerisms, etc… Exploit these flaws to add dramatic elements to the game.

Give them a viola.

This is a saying I learned in school. It means give them something unique. Some habit, some mannerism, some hobby that adds to their character and makes them unique from any other no matter how closely they adopt character archetypes. Two-Face’s scarred coin is the best example I could come up with.

Background

Background is overlooked in many games, but a history is very, very important. It gives the character relativity and helps show that they too are subjects of time. I think James (dad) of Fallout 3 has a very substantial history that enriches his character and a player’s endearment or understanding of him.

Make them expressive

A mute character that is super tolerant of pain and unable to have relationships makes a very dull character. For entertainment sake and to give the player something to attach to, a character needs to be loud. They should contort and respond to pain to the point where the player hurts. They should express emotions especially the darker ones of loss, pain, guilt, depression.

These techniques can also be used to embellish the NPC’s of the world. Although they may not be the center point of conflict or just a bystander in a game, it is equally important to populate a world with people that the player can relate to. NPCs that respond to the player and their environment are more convincing than walking dialogue boxes.

Place

The second literary element is place. I won’t pretend to be an expert on level design and environments.  I simply want to touch upon what tactics can be used to create a world that avoids disillusionment no matter how surreal or fantastical it is.

The main objective is to give a player a sense of place. He needs to be oriented and begin to understand his world quickly—to the point where, how it will respond to him becomes predictable. Think of New York City. Would you ever step in front of a taxi? Hell, nah! This isn’t from some experience of being struck by a cab, but simply through an understanding of the city’s very fast pace and every-man-for-him-self mentality.

Detail, detail, and more detail

Nothing makes a place more believable than nitty-gritty detail and I’ve never found a case of too much—maybe in novels—but never in games. I’d like to use StarCraft 2 for this one. Between each mission, the player is allowed to explore the virtual briefing environments. Raynor’s bar is packed with details to explore. I’ll never forget on the bulletin board between lvl 2 and 3 there is a letter of gratitude written by one of the Mar Sara colonists accompanied by a child’s stick figure drawing off to the side and out of focus. It alludes to a much larger world beyond the scope that the player’s been provided with.

Rules

And I don’t mean well working physics engines and un-bugged mechanics. I mean maintaining a universal continuity and established order. This may seem counterintuitive in fantasy worlds, but actually this is when these rules are most important to maintain the suspension of disbelief.

Acknowledge that things are irregular in your world and don’t be afraid of delving into pseudoscience for explanations; it helps make the circumstances more believable like the mass effect in Mass Effect enabling faster than light travel and psionics. It tells the player there is a method to the madness they are experiencing, and the world becomes more predictable as they start to accept the science that governs it.

Dynamic Worlds

A world becomes alive through dynamic and responsive environments. The environments need to be ever changing to set the scene: weather patterns, cultural responses, physical destruction and growth. The world should respond to stimulus whether plot driven or caused by ludic actions. That’s why shooters with destructible environments get such high acclaim.

Setting the Mood

“It was a dark and stormy night” cliché but to the point. The setting needs to be defined within the player’s first impressions of the world. That’s why dark environments are used in horror survival games and why the new setting for Bioshock Infinite is raising much concern with their big bright open spaces in the skies of Columbia.

A strong sense of place orients a player. If it isn’t stable enough, people will suffer disillusionment. You can’t let the dreamer know that he’s dreaming. You start to shake things up too much and you may break the dream.

Conflict

The third and final literary element I wish to highlight is conflict. In videogames especially, it is a challenge to see beyond the potential of physical conflict. Man vs Man and Man vs World. After all, most videogames are packed with high intensity action. Sadly though, that takes attention away from a very important form of conflict. Man vs Self.

When dealing with conflict and a character, nothing humanizes him more than to see the impact the drama is having on him personally. Ask yourself, “How does the character contribute to the conflict himself?” I touched briefly upon this under character, but here is a more in-depth look at how to fully draw a player into the conflict of a game. 

Innate Conflict

The conflict needs to be innate. The main character’s flaws and attributes need to be what develops conflict. Progression through conflict should be character driven, not plot driven. A personal quest pulls the players into the character’s world more and helps them sympathize with their virtual avatar. The closer the character, the closer the player is to the conflict and the more enjoyable and emotionally evoking the experience will be.

Never a dull moment

Conflict acts as the glue of the world and the people within it—it’s what keeps people engaged with what’s going on. In a story, everything has conflict even character interactions. A conversation about the weather is boring and superficial; a disagreement about how the player handled or plans to handle something in the game is much more interesting and brings out the reality and consequence of the player’s ludic actions.

Conflict will define what the player’s role in the game will be and validates a player’s participation, grounding him ever deeper into the world.

 Conclusion

Developing a story with rich character, place, and conflict will provide a player with an ensnaring gaming experience that he can’t help but get caught up in. It works nicely when considered early on in production and carried out through the whole development process. Getting a player attached to his character pulls him into the world and validates the role he has to play within the conflict (the story) of the game.  Together, these three elements create an engaging experience that will generate a response in the enchanted participant. I encourage people to share more examples of when these techniques were used in game development and worked for them. 


Related Jobs

Digital Extremes
Digital Extremes — LONDON, Ontario, Canada
[10.24.14]

UI ARTIST/DESIGNER
University of Central Florida, School of Visual Arts and Design
University of Central Florida, School of Visual Arts and Design — Orlando, Florida, United States
[10.24.14]

Assistant Professor in Digital Media (Game Design)
The College of New Jersey
The College of New Jersey — Ewing, New Jersey, United States
[10.24.14]

Assistant Professor - Interactive Multi Media - Tenure Track
Bohemia Interactive Simulations
Bohemia Interactive Simulations — Prague, Czech Republic
[10.24.14]

Game Designer






Comments


Nick Powell
profile image
But what you're suggesting is not remotely 'literary'. You're just detailing how certain things in video games could be better.



The problem with those Bethesda games is not a lack of Dickensian detail (though that could help). It's the philosophy of the design, which is completely antithetical to the notion of 'literature'. Those are games designed not to engage the gamer's brain or reflexes, but to keep them playing for long stretches of time (via countless generic caves that we think might just maybe have our next slightly superior sword hiding in them) simply because we're more likely to buy a game if we think it's a good investment. So of course there's "disillusionment", because even the most addled gamer will eventually have a moment where they realize their neurons are sipping beer on an adirondack.



The actual 'literature' of games has nothing to do with flawed characters or story conclusions. Even in *literature* that's not literature. Those are bullet points in an instructional book for beginning writers. In the world of video games, 'literature' is the block-stacking in Tetris, or the immaculate balance between Zerg/Human/Terran, or the pervasive fast-moving playfulness of Portal.



The 'literary elements' you promote are the path to mediocrity.

Brandon Battersby
profile image
Dear Nick,



Trying saying that to the greatly successful and story conscious studio of Bioware. Next time, before you comment on an article, read the surgeon's general warning "Keep in mind, this is a topic regarding games that utilize narrative agents and have at least the slightest hint of story implementation."



Thanks for your creative and playful interpretation of the word literature, but if we are going to be loose with terminology, id prefer you keep your comments to yourself... Literary Elements--Literary Terms ... "Structure" includes all the elements in a story. The final objective is to see the story as a whole and to become aware of how the parts are put together to produce a unified effect."



That's what I am talking about. And if you truly believe that this doesn't play into the success of game development then I hope you are on your way out of the industry....



Thank you everyone else for your comments.

Nick Powell
profile image
I've read that surgeon's general warning. It's worn like a badge by nearly every 'serious' game that's produced today. I think it's the result of an inferiority complex.



I left out my overarching thesis: modern games focus far too much on narrative. It's an aspiration that does damage to the genre because that's not what this medium is. Video games will never reach the exemplary heights of narrative achieved by novels or movies, where narrative *is* the medium. That's what I meant by 'path to mediocrity'. It's like a football team breaking into a dance routine in the middle of a game, or a movie producer deciding that half the screen time will be occupied by typed poetry. Poetry is great, and good poetry is better than most movies, but there's no reason for it to be on the big screen. That screen is for the art and composition of moving pictures, at their best.



When games like Mass Effect and Final Fantasy Tactics try to make their worth based on the strength of their narrative, they doom themselves to failure. People will disagree with me, but Mass Effect isn't half as good as the worst Lovecraft short story; FFT reached for grandness, and fell far short due to the basic restrictions of time and budget. Those are things that this medium wasn't built for, and it needs to remember its soul. You're swept up in this current evolutionary phase where games think they can achieve some kind of narrative prowess (yes, I've played Bioshock, and I was impressed by almost everything *but* the story), but that's just not leading anywhere constructive.

Brandon Battersby
profile image
Actually, there has been great bounds in poetry toward integrating visual arts with the craft. In fact some poet laureates, namely Robert Pinsky, would say poetry is meant to be spoken out loud, because there is a conscious ploy of phonetics and sounds. Alliteration is a literary device that can only be appreciated when voiced.



I leave it at, I disagree with your narrow view as to what exactly the gaming medium is. I think multimedia and fine art forms have made many bounds together and have light years ahead of them.



Play Knights of the Old Republic, and tell me that game isn't fantastic and entertaining... No authority claims a game needs to be anything else than that, and frankly that game's success was driven by its narrative.

Cody Kostiuk
profile image
Though the article is full of useful tidbits for creating engaging gaming worlds, I believe that disillusionment does not stem from a lack of anything described in this article. I think it merely becomes apparent when a game doesn't meet our expectations in some manner... and, of course, that differs from player to player.



I really liked Fallout 3 initially. I was blown away for the first twenty hours or so. Then things began to slowly fall apart when I realized that the game didn't model character development and relationships in any meaningful way. The game was full of interesting moral dilemmas, but nothing seemed to really matter (on a human, emotional level at least). I didn't empathize with any characters in the game, save for Desmond in Point Lookout. Fallout 3 is still a great game, but I had to stop playing it as the world became too stale despite the wonderfully crafted environment and incredible exploration to be had. I think Fallout 3 covered (maybe not incredibly well) a lot, if not all, of the points in this article... yet I still became disillusioned eventually.



That said, this article is very informative and I really appreciated it.



If others are looking for a cheat sheet for creating plots, setting, conflicts, characters, etc... I highly recommend a book called the Dungeon Master's Design Kit. It's an old AD&D adventure creation book that I still dust off and reference. I'm still amazed how well crafted it is and I've never seen anything else like it.

Haris Orkin
profile image
Okay, that's a little harsh, Nick. I agree that what Brandon is talking about is creative writing 101. The best designed (and written) games already incorporate many of the points he brought up. But many games still don't incorporate any of them. Which is probably what inspired him to write the blog.



You'll find pretty much everything he's talking about in Drake's Fortune. There's no reason the design elements can't be tied tightly to the character, story, and plot. I happen to be someone who likes games with stories and characters. (And great level design and game play.) Starcraft 2 did a good job of incorporating both. As did Red Dead Redemption. I try to do everything he's talking about in every game I work on. The same literary techniques that are used to create characters and story in novels or film can be used to make games more immersive. Of course games are a unique medium with different needs and requirements, but that's a given.

Armand Kossayan
profile image
As "simple" as these bits of advise may be, they are still often ignored in many games. It's refreshing to see this sort of conversation, and helpful to be reminded of the elements that make an interesting story.

Yensei Sensei
profile image
Nick,



You mention that modern games focus far too much on narrative, that may be true, modern games do focus on narrative and should. We have more tools to do this now days than ever before. Back in the early days, it was hard for artist to create meaningful narrative, today we have HD visuals and hi-fidelity sound, motion capture and professional writers at standby.



Yet we are still flooded with games with awful stories, that its slowly become a signature of games, using movie tropes and almost caricatures for characters.



Games are a unique medium, a viewer is not only viewing anymore, his actively taking part in the narrative, pushing it forward. Of course a lot of games fail at this, putting the player behind the wheel of a character, where the narrative is merely a cut scene/ a story in the background, something that does not engage the player.



The weakness of many game narratives these days has many complex reasons, I think Daniel Loyd in ‘Extra Credits’ summed it up nicely in some his commentary on this problem.


none
 
Comment: