Gamasutra: The Art & Business of Making Gamesspacer
View All     RSS
October 21, 2014
arrowPress Releases
October 21, 2014
PR Newswire
View All
View All     Submit Event





If you enjoy reading this site, you might also want to check out these UBM Tech sites:


 
Counting Sheep: A Catherine Analysis
by Josh Bycer on 08/05/11 01:58:00 pm   Featured Blogs

The following blog post, unless otherwise noted, was written by a member of Gamasutra’s community.
The thoughts and opinions expressed are those of the writer and not Gamasutra or its parent company.

 

Catherine, the latest game from Atlus, was an unknown entity for some time. Early trailers from Japan had gamers guessing and there was a point that no one was sure that it would be ported. With the game finally released, I can definitely say that Catherine is not only one of the most unique games to come out this year, but could easily be the most unique game to come from Atlus.

Catherine's gameplay is split between puzzle solving and light adventure. The only part of the story I'm going to talk about is what has been released and put in reviews. Players will control Vincent, an early thirty-something slacker software developer. He is in a long term relationship with Katherine and has been enjoying life so far. However, Katherine has begun talking about taking things further, such as having kids and marriage. Vincent likes things the way they are, but before he has a chance to talk more about this, someone new enters his life.

While drinking one night, Vincent meets Catherine, a blond bombshell who is as easy going as him. The next morning he finds himself in bed with Catherine and in the middle of a love triangle. Now, if this was a soap opera, their relationship issues would be solved by long pauses and dramatic music. Since this is a game from the Persona team, you know that things are going to get weird.

Every night, Vincent finds himself in a nightmare world with all the other cheaters out there, now transformed into sheep. To survive, Vincent must climb up an ever collapsing tower to reach freedom. If Vincent fails to reach the top and dies in his dreams, he'll join the list of men who have been found dead in the morning.

If you haven't guessed by now, Catherine is not your usual game; the story is one of the more interesting ones I've seen in some time. Vincent isn't out to save the world, he is just trying to figure out what to do with two lovely ladies in his life, and the situation grows out of control fast.

Let's talk about the gameplay, starting with the adventure side. Every night before he goes to sleep, Vincent hangs out at his favorite bar with his friends. There are a variety of things for the player to do such as talking with the patrons or having a few drinks. Vincent will occasionally get text messages on his phone from both women, which the player can decide how he responds back. The choices will tilt a law/chaos scale that determines Vincent's responses in cut-scenes and the ending of the game.

There is also an arcade game that is essentially the nightmare puzzle solving, minus the time limit, allowing players a chance to improve their skills. Each time Vincent talks to someone, time moves forward and people may leave the bar, or new ones will show up. Eventually, Vincent will have to go home and sleep and that's when the nightmare starts.

The puzzle solving looks simple at first, but there are a lot of factors for the player to deal with. Vincent has to push and pull blocks to create a way up the tower. He can only climb up one block high walls, requiring the player to make effective stairs. Blocks connect to each other at their edges, allowing Vincent to create paths with the blocks suspending in thin air. Complicating matters are the various types of blocks Vincent will encounter along with the tower collapsing from the bottom up, take too long and Vincent is done for and the player will lose a life.

Figuring out the optimal path up the tower is where the challenge of the game is. Players are graded by how fast they reach the top and at the end of the night will receive an award based on their performance. The awards are used to unlock bonus materials like additional songs in the jukebox. Each night is made up of various levels, after the player beats a section they'll be taken to a landing where they can converse with the other trapped men.

During these breaks, the player can save their game and watch tutorial videos showing off new techniques for climbing the tower. Money, earned from climbing the tower can be used to buy an item, but that will lower the player's chances at getting a good award at the end. Each landing is concluded with the player being asked a morality question that will tilt the law/chaos scale from earlier.

To complete a night, players will have to get through a boss battle. Here, not only does the player have to figure out how to climb the tower, but they are also chased by a manifestation of Vincent's current fear. Each boss will either affect the blocks or attack Vincent, or both, requiring the player to pay as much attention to it, as they do to the puzzle solving.

If you have been reading any reviews on Catherine, one common mention is on the game's difficulty. Having started on hard, got completely stumped and dropped to medium, then considered going to easy I can conclude that Catherine is hard. The three difficulty levels (with a somewhat hidden very easy mode) each have their own puzzle layout. On normal and below, players can redo their actions to a certain point allowing them to erase a mistake or try a different option. The difficulty is going to turn off a lot of gamers, because of how different it is from a traditional game.

In other games, such as action titles, there is always feedback that lets the player know that they made a mistake. Maybe they blocked when they should have dodge, or watched the enemy pattern more. Feedback allows the player to see what they did wrong and improve for next time. However, with Catherine being a puzzle game above all else, there is no feedback to let the player know if they're doing fine, or if the last block they pulled has put them into an unsolvable situation.

There are no new abilities for Vincent to learn, with exception to the items, all progress is based off of the player's skill. The quicker you learn the patterns to look for in block placement and what to do, the easier the game will become. However, if you get stuck, without any feedback as to how you’re playing, things can become impossible.

Which is what happened to me, I got stuck at a puzzle and had no idea how to get through it. Without any feedback, I was banging my head against the wall for an hour. Finally I had to turn to YouTube to watch the solution.

Besides the difficulty I have a few design issues with the game. First, is with having a "lives" mechanic. In Catherine, you can replay a puzzle as many times as you want as long as you have enough lives to do that. However running out of lives just means restarting at your last save point, which you can do before you start a puzzle. This feels arbitrary to me and an excuse for the player to watch the "game-over “screen. On normal, at one point, I had at least 80 lives, the only time I ran out of lives was during my first attempt at hard mode, but it still felt like an arbitrary mechanic.

The controls take some getting used to and even at the end of the game; I was still having some problems with them. The issue is that Vincent's movement is based on his relation to the camera, when he's standing, left moves him left and so on. However, when he's hanging on the side of blocks or moving behind the tower, the controls become reverse. This becomes troublesome when Vincent is behind the tower as the camera doesn't shift to show that view, which has a good chance of getting the player stuck there.

I wish that the developers spent more time with giving the player training videos, or maybe even an actual tutorial. The videos can only be viewed on the corresponding landings, meaning if you forget how one went, you're SOL. Having access to more help and information would help reduce the difficulty curve.

With the difficulty and unusual subject matter good reasons for gamers to avoid Catherine, I hope that a lot of people try this game. The art style was amazing, especially with the later levels. Going back to the story, having finished the game and got one of the many endings, I found this to be one of my favorite game stories in some time. Even with the nightmares and sheep, this is still a love story and Vincent isn't a super hero or whiny teen, he's an adult stuck in a very sticky situation. For gamers clamoring for something original, Catherine easily fits that bill, but make sure that you know what to expect before jumping in, or you may find yourself heading for a long fall.

Josh.


Related Jobs

Rumble Entertainment, Inc.
Rumble Entertainment, Inc. — San Mateo, California, United States
[10.21.14]

Technical Product Manager - Platform (Chinese Fluency)
Zindagi Games
Zindagi Games — Camarillo, California, United States
[10.21.14]

MOBILE Art Director
InnoGames GmbH
InnoGames GmbH — Hamburg, Germany
[10.21.14]

Mobile Developer C++ (m/f)
Treyarch / Activision
Treyarch / Activision — Santa Monica, California, United States
[10.21.14]

Senior UI Artist (temporary) Treyarch






Comments


Mattie Brice
profile image
I didn't find the story well crafted, and the only thing remarkable about it is that the 'hero' isn't really doing much that is typically thought as heroic. It is an interesting angle, with the person's life being what the 'adventure' is, however nothing is really complicated or convincing. I find it hard that Vincent is actually a character you can truly relate to, and that all of the gender stereotypes this game reinforces is really realistic. I also don't think the story grew from the design; it felt like they wanted a personal drama story and make the tower climbing an obvious metaphor to it, but really, they didn't speak to each other. I was disappointed with the game to follow from Persona 3 & 4's creators, especially with how short it is with the skant replay value it has despite charging the same amount a 60+ hour RPG would cost.

Josh Bycer
profile image
I think they intended the babel challenges to make up for the replay value, as each one is randomized each time.

Mattie Brice
profile image
I think they spread themselves thin by creating Babel and also the multiple endings, which on paper makes it seem like the game has a lot more to offer, but you really have to enjoy those puzzles in order to get the full content of the game. It's more of a puzzle game than it is anything else, and seeing the general reaction to them, they were more challenges to get through rather than fun activities you want to do over and over again (might be colored by my own experience). It shows how you can see a lot of effort and interesting ideas went into the game but still didn't have a harmonious alignment of all their elements.

Kasan Wright
profile image
Good article. I think you articulated many of the pros and cons of the game well.



I have to say I really enjoyed this game. It took me by surprise and kept surprising me the more I kept playing it. I started the game on easy mode, so I had what was effectively the "normal" level of challenge and the only real issue I ran into while playing was how the controls reverse when you climbed to the other side of the cubes. This control issue reminded me of some problems I had playing Mario Galaxy when it first came out...



As far as the story, I found it fairly engrossing early on as I wanted to know what was going on with all the dying men and how it related to me as the player. It then became more suspenseful as the true conflict began to emerge. I did find the inciting incident (the initial meeting with Catharine) a bit too coincidental and haphazard, but in the end, it all made sense once you learned who she really was...



The puzzle gameplay itself was surprisingly addictive to me (and I don't play that many puzzle games). I played the arcade version for hours and really had fun in the competitive multi-player with a friend after beating the game.



Overall, Catharine was one of the most memorable and compelling gaming experiences I've had all year (and I play a crap ton of games that come out in the commercial AND indie space). Sure the game has its issues, but for me those things didn't overshadow the total experience.



I hope Atlus keeps on publishing great, unique content like this. The market needs more diversity in the commercial space. It's nice to see something so fresh in a sea of mundane.



-Kaz

asdf fdsa
profile image
Catherine makes me smile, alot. I have been following this title for quite some time now and its really intriguing. Atlus is a japanese company with many many underrated gems gems under its belt for decades now. Catherine is different, because with catherine they fully realized that modern videogames, and especially in the west sell on marketing and media hype alone. The actual quality and content of a title, or its depth of gameplay does not matter. Awesome job on the marketing guys and i think finally atlus gets abit of the recognition they deserved anyway. Lets see if other japanese midsize comapnies follow suit and swing the marketing hammer fiercely.


none
 
Comment: