Gamasutra: The Art & Business of Making Gamesspacer
View All     RSS
September 19, 2014
arrowPress Releases
September 19, 2014
PR Newswire
View All





If you enjoy reading this site, you might also want to check out these UBM Tech sites:


Platinum's Kamiya Voices Concern Over Missing  Okami  Credits
Platinum's Kamiya Voices Concern Over Missing Okami Credits
May 1, 2008 | By Chris Remo

May 1, 2008 | By Chris Remo
Comments
    7 comments
More: Console/PC



Acclaimed Okami designer Hideki Kamiya has expressed frustration with publisher Capcom's decision to omit the original development team credits from the United States version of Ready At Dawn's Okami Wii port.

Kamiya, also known as the creator of Devil May Cry and Viewtiful Joe as well as the designer of Resident Evil 2, currently works at recently formed studio Platinum Games (nee Seeds Inc.) with several other high-profile former Capcom employees.

Okami was developed for PlayStation 2 by Capcom's now-defunct Clover Studio, which Kamiya co-founded, and was released in 2006. As announced in October of 2007, Daxter developer Ready At Dawn ported the game to the Wii, in a version released in March of this year.

The designer posted a lengthy message on the absent credits via Platinum's Facebook blog. It is reprinted in full below:

"The other day, I was surfing the net looking at some sites and I was a bit shocked and disappointed by what I found... Apparently, in Okami for the Nintendo Wii, released last week in the US, the staff credits after the ending have been cut from the game. The fan comments that I read were in English, so I wasnít sure if I was misunderstanding things, but our localization staff checked into the issue and confirmed it as fact.

I donít know the details behind why the staff roll was cut... But what do you all think about the issue? Iím not disappointed because my name was removed from the game. Of course, we all have pride in our work; we all want to stand up and say ďI made this!Ē Yet more importantly, I find it extremely regrettable that the
omoi that went into the staff roll is gone from the game as well. (Translator's note: The Japanese word - 想い Ė omoi Ė is best defined as a combination of thoughts, emotions, and messages. Iíve left it in Japanese as I feel it better suits Kamiya-sanís intentions.)

It takes a great deal of time and energy to complete a game. The more difficult the challenges a player faces, the greater their sense of accomplishment at the end. Players who complete a game want to feel this sense of accomplishment, whether it is because the game was difficult or simply because the journey was long.

In Okamiís case, I did my best to lower the level of difficulty in battle; however, as the majestic adventure itself requires 20-30 hours, and you can spend even more time devoted to the game, it is clear that completing Okami is no simple task.

Of course, not everyone will reach the ending, so players who do should what the staff roll filled with this
omoi. That is why every game that Iíve guided does not end by simply introducing the staff, but ends full of this special omoi that bring a sense of closure to the game.

In Resident Evil 2, the Zapping System gave way to two different endings, a Sub-Ending and a Main Ending, and each of these endings was accompanied by a completely different kind of music. The Sub-Ending featured a ballad meant to signify the healing of the main character after their battle ends.

The Main Ending played against a valiant rock song meant to praise users for their mastery of the game. Even though they were simply credits, they were meant to wash players in the emotions of their post-game experience.

Devil May Cryís staff roll came along with advances in technology that allowed us to play video with the credits (something I had wanted to do with Resident Evil 2 but gave up on because of compression artifacts), so I changed the video along with the music.

The beginning of the credits sequence, coming directly after Trish and Dante head off towards a new fight, is a video of the hero and heroine in a balletic display of martial prowess matched to an uptempo track. This crossfades into a gentle choral song in the second half, as the video transitions to images of the sea based upon the idea of motherly love found in Devil May Cryís story.

Viewtiful Joeís credits were like a curtain call, meant to intertwine with the gameís theme of movies and the incredible events that took place within. It came from the idea that within the game, your friends were your friends and your enemies your enemies, but once everything came to a close, one and all were friends!

Thus it was like a wrap party, introducing the cast along with a medley of each stageís music. Since the game had elements of comedy, we wanted people to feel how much fun we had making the game via the credits.

Finally, we arrive at Okami. Since Iím sure there are plenty of people who will still be playing Okami, I wonít go into specific details... However, it was the first time for us to make a long adventure, and so the staff roll was filled with all of the omoi appropriate for the end of a long journey.

Of course, these werenít just my
omoi. They were the omoi of everyone who worked on the project, put together in a moment of bliss held out just for those who completed the journey. It was a special staff roll for a special moment. And now it is gone. All of it. ...Itís incredibly disappointing and sad.

Not just in Okamiís case, but with all the games we make... I want as many people to play them as possible. Everything is for the players who are kind enough to play our work. Thatís the feeling we carry with us as we go about the business of creating games. Even though I have absolutely no interest in the business of gaming (apologies to my bosses), a userís joy is a creatorís joy, and having more joyful users is always better. If you can prove a gameís worth, and get it into the hands of many gamers, this should lead to sales and a greater contribution to the company at large... Right? (If Iím wrong... apologies to my bosses!)

Even if we donít see the results right away, we know that when our spirit shines through, the flower of success will bloom. Then everyone, the creators, the players, and the businessmen, will all be happy. To me, that is the ideal.

I wonder who could have possibly been pleased with Okamiís staff roll being cut? Iíve long decided that the minute I canít make games that users can say ďThis is fun!Ē towards, I would quit this job. However, until the very last second, I plan to keep the feeling in my heart that everything I do is to make the player happy."


The Okami situation bears similarity to a recent incident involving the crediting of last year's Manhunt 2. Rockstar Vienna had developed the game until the studio's closure in 2006, at which point Rockstar London took over the project - but credited none of the Rockstar Vienna developers in the finished version.

Producer Jurie Horneman spoke out on the matter in a weblog post, including the names and positions of dozens of uncredited Manhunt 2 staffers.

[UPDATE: When Okami players asked this question on the official Capcom.com messageboards last week, Capcom's community manager Seth Killian explained:

"The credits were removed because they were a pre-rendered movie that contained the Clover logo. We have no legal right to use the Clover logo in a game they were not involved with directly. We also didn't have the source to the credit movie itself, so we couldn't just use it and remove the Clover logo."]


Related Jobs

Phosphor Games Studio
Phosphor Games Studio — Chicago, Illinois, United States
[09.18.14]

Game Producer
Trion Worlds
Trion Worlds — Redwood City, California, United States
[09.18.14]

Senior Gameplay Engineer
Heavy Iron Studios, Inc.
Heavy Iron Studios, Inc. — Los Angeles, California, United States
[09.18.14]

Game Programming Intern
Heavy Iron Studios, Inc.
Heavy Iron Studios, Inc. — Los Angeles, California, United States
[09.18.14]

Gameplay and Engine Programmer










Comments


Kale Menges
profile image
Kind of insulting on Capcom's part. This is the kind of thing I have nightmares about.

Anonymous
profile image
Ditto.. I think it's stupid that companies pull that crap and hold it over the heads of their employees. Often developers that have worked years on a project will receive no credit if they leave the company (even for personal/medical reasons) before the physical ship date. I can only hope that Capcom officially apologizes and publishes a list of the missing developers names. It's the right thing to do.

E Zachary Knight
profile image
This definitely annoys me. I have gotten behind the idea of properly crediting the developers behind a game and it really bugs me to see it not happen.



I wonder Jason with the IGDA will be saying something about this.

Thomas Grove
profile image
Ouch. Even if that was the real reason, they could have just placed a mosaic over the logo, leaving the rest of the credits intact!

Anonymous
profile image
"Did not have the source"? Please, that's ridiculous. You must have no understanding of ethics if you didn't think of taking the time to copy the information on the credit screen. People spent a few years of their lives to make that product, all to have their names covered over by a porting team.



Every project I spent my time on I made sure everyone who helped was acknowledged, and if it was a porting project, than I would understand my place and give the real creators their due.



Some people in the industry are really immature...

Brandon Sheffield
profile image
furthermore, even if that were the real reason, they could've asked the platinum games people for permission, and no doubt gotten it - unless they were afraid of having to pay them again.

Nicolas Casanova
profile image
The people behind this game should feel realy insulted and disappointed.



The credit pre rendered video should have been done again without the Clover logo.


none
 
Comment: