It Can Be Done
In a meeting with medical experts at University of Pittsburgh's Medical Center, they recommended designing a way to increase a child's heart rate when playing, as this would exponentially increase the possibility of a meaningful workout.
We immediately thought of the success of the DDR dance pad. After extensive research, we couldn't find any other game that re-designed the dance pad to be used for a non-dancing/simulation game.
On the one hand, we were excited to try something entirely fresh: combining the Wii remote and floor pad to work as one user interface for an action-adventure. On the other hand, we were a bit concerned that this combination had not already been accomplished by a professional developer.
Was there something we were missing? Would it feel completely unintuitive to combine the two peripherals? We didn't know until we finished our initial prototype, but we were excited by the possibilities in front of us. We had two astronomically successful devices that were proven successes in millions of homes; why couldn't we make them work as one?
With the foot input established and re-purposed, the floodgates opened with ideas as we were able to literally place the child in a video game hero's shoes.
To make our hero jump over a chasm while being chased by a menacing enemy, the player will jump in their living room; when our hero unleashes a three-step melee combo on an antagonist, the player will not only swing their arms with the Wii remote, but move their feet in conjunction to mimic the attack of their avatar.
The child will be actively engaged in a traditional action-adventure experience, but their mind will be focused in the flow of the gameplay and aesthetic beauty of the world, not on burning calories.
After finishing our first complete tutorial and world, we believe this can be done, and we're working to prove it with our currently PC-based project (pictured above), The Winds of Orbis: An Active-Adventure.
|
Printer-Friendly Version
Athens 2004. And really, you can use the pad with any game, just need to contend with the remappings. There are some interesting, if anecdotal, examples around from the post-PS2/DDR craze.
Again congratulations on such an excellent project. Your statements about dissuading children from going outside echoes my philosophy about exergames. Exergames should not replace regular physical activities, sports and games; however they have the potential to attract the normally sedentary children to engage in a different movement form that they might find enjoyable. Exergames like Orbis really need to be supported at home, school, and community to make a difference in a child’s level of health. However if exergames can get inactive kids to become more active and do it often enough, their new found joy in moving might transfer over to other activities (perhaps non-exergame based). I consider exergames to be potential “Gateway Games”.
For exergames like Orbis to make a make an impact, developers like yourselves must continue to foster a) joyful movement, b) social supportive environments, c) autonomy (aka decision making ability), and d) building their sense of competency. Well done and keep up the great work!
I agree any game can be mapped to a DDR pad, though. Soul Calibur is a great example. To DeAngelis' point though, I think that an open-ended action-adventure world has not yet been done.
Why can't you just present your game as a fun way for people to play and be active? A fun, exciting way to be immersed in the game world?
Climbing on the anti-obesity bandwagon opens you up to negative attention from those who feel that any videogame is evil, and discussion of the game risks being buried under hordes rushing in to tout THEIR weight-loss program (diet spam is ridiculously common these days).
You also risk attracting a lot of criticism for misrepresentation of the facts. You write: "There is an unfortunate correlation between the increase in child obesity and the popularity of video games. In 1999, the average child played video games for 29 minutes a day. According to the Entertainment Software Association (ESA), that number has more than doubled to approximately 63 minutes per day in 2007."
Considering that the CDC reports that there has been NO INCREASE in child obesity since 1999, it seems you've just neatly proved that there's no correlation at all.
Anyway. I like the concept of the game. I like the idea of getting kids active and letting them have fun exploring a world. But I deplore your marketing strategy.
I am a member of the project team for this game and we by no means were jumping on a bandwagon or attempting to champion child obesity for our own good. After talking with doctors and other medical professionals they were all interested in using the game specifically to fight obesity, because it will very likely work extremely well. There are no false facts put forth here and you should check the CDC site again about the "no increase since 1999" (http://www.cdc.gov/nchs/products/pubs/pubd/hestats/overweight/HealthEstat1206.gi
f).
When we pitched this project to the faculty we wanted to explore using active inputs in a new way. We wanted to break out of the conventional sports or dance related game and try something we had all loved as kids: action-adventures.
I hope that our game can make a difference and potentially get kids (and adults) moving because it is more fun to play it on a dancepad than it is with just a controller. Hope this clears some stuff up for you.
As a parent of an obese child (I was in a bad mood when in my earlier post I referred to my kid as a "fatty"), I am encouraged when I see game developers try to combat obsesity. I would compare it to eco-friendly business practices. Just because it's a corporate move, doesn't mean that it's evil. One could describe this type of game as more than a "fun, simple game", but a socially conscious gaming endeavor.
I would love to play that game myself, unfortunaly here in Brazil there are a great problem: Such hardware is really expensive here (a legaly bought Wii console for example is 1200 USD Oo and even if it was 120 USD it is well beyond most people salary, meaning the the majority of the population would never buy one even ilegally and used at same time)
I believe you have read this back to yourself?
"shudder* I realise it's hardly unusual for gamasutra articles to be full of PR-speak about how great one's project is, but this really comes across as a slimy attempt to try and muscle in on the moral panic over obesity while misrepresenting the facts, which is just as repugnant to me as any "Video Games Make Our Children Into Killers!" nonsense would be."
Make our children into killers?
= Makes our children fat?
please point out anywhere in this amazing project that says video games make children "obese".
I dont understand why you dont see this as a positive thing, every industry is jumping on the "Green earth movement" in terms of reshaping our society into a healthy long living prosperous one. This is when its all starting, and Nintendo KNEW IT (Wii/Wii Fit). In terms of other industrys, take a look at the hospitality industry, http://www.pureroom.com/
soon hotels everywhere will be dust free. How is that any different from videogames being fun, addicting, and "healthy?".
The way you state that jumping on this wagon attracts flamers and critisism from other industries is almost as if you feel there is no competition with the game industry at all.
Isnt it common sense, that gym's and weight loss programs would do whatever it takes to keep other industries from stealing revenue?
We all know everyone is turning there eye's on the game industry.
In an effort to turn the attention from putting Georgina in her place, I would like to return again to the positive nature of this article.
In this day and age, it has become more the norm to raise a family within city limits rather than uprooting yourself and carting everything off to the suburbs. It is also more common to find that both parents now work, thus leaving no one at home for when kids get out of school. Many parents ask that their children stay indoors until they get home from work. This leaves the kids inside for hours a day, at which time, they can snack unsupervised, watch TV, or play video games. By the time the parents get home, there is still time to play outside, but not much. I love the that more people are seeing the opportunity to create a remedy to this concern that many parents have. If you can find a way to simulate outdoor activity while remaining indoors, why wouldn't you take advantage of this, especially for after school activities and to cure winter boredom. I commend you, Garth, for bringing to view a positive remedy for the video game induced couch potato dilemma. They say that the children of today are our future, so here's to making our future a healthy, happy one!
Have you read the *actual scientific studies* from the official government agencies measuring American health, or are you basing your knowledge of the subject solely on a TV newscaster showing you pictures of fat people?
http://jama.ama-assn.org/cgi/content/abstract/299/20/2401
But don't take my word for it, do a simple websearch for childhood obesity plateau, you'll see dozens of articles talking about it. There has been no increase since 1999.
Since 1999 was the exact year that the article here chose to use as its basis for showing rising use of videogames correlating to a rise in child obesity, it's quite obviously problematic to anyone following the science. Had he chosen a different year, or left this "correlation" part out entirely, it wouldn't be so obvious.
-Mex
Did you read the article or just the abstract? This is from the editorial the doctors wrote on the study:
"However, it is too early to know whether these data reflect a true plateau or a statistical aberration in an inexorable epidemic, and pre-existing racial/ethnic disparities show no sign of abating. On one point there is no uncertainty: without substantial declines in prevalence, the public health toll of childhood obesity will continue to mount, because it can take many years for an obese child to develop life-threatening complications."
The web search you did likely pointed to a number of news articles all talking about this single study. No plateau has yet been proven, and even if the obesity rate has stopped rising that doesn't mean it is no longer a problem.
If you would like more information on videogames and childhood obesity it can be found here:
http://www.sciencedirect.com/science?_ob=ArticleURL&_udi=B6WH0-4BC2K43-1&_user=1
0&_rdoc=1&_fmt=&_orig=search&_sort=d&view=c&_acct=C000050221&_version=1&_urlVers
ion=0&_userid=10&md5=155ef3407a5452f0faf859c6cf03bd1c
http://www.nature.com/ijo/journal/v29/n8/abs/0802994a.html
http://www.nature.com/ijo/journal/v29/n2s/abs/0803064a.html
http://www.nature.com/oby/journal/v15/n10/abs/oby2007296a.html
(I can keep going....)
Here is some info on how even slightly active games can help improve energy expenditure in children:
http://pediatrics.aappublications.org/cgi/content/abstract/118/6/e1831
Dance Aerobics
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=LAOUTCbAPGc
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dance_Aerobics_(video_game)
There was even a sort of dance music note module in there too.
The downside is that someone is going to subvert active input devices with controller remaps.
Have you investigated how to make devices that can't readily be remapped?