Gamasutra: The Art & Business of Making Gamesspacer
Postmortem: Humble Hearts' Dust: An Elysian Tail

Printer-Friendly VersionPrinter-Friendly Version
View All     RSS
April 20, 2014
arrowPress Releases
April 20, 2014
PR Newswire
View All





If you enjoy reading this site, you might also want to check out these UBM TechWeb sites:


 
Postmortem: Humble Hearts' Dust: An Elysian Tail

October 31, 2012 Article Start Previous Page 3 of 4 Next
 

5. PAX East 2012

Aside from the Dream.Build.Play win in 2009, and an "XBLA Announce" Trailer for E3 2010, Dust: AET remained dark as I toiled away in my dungeon. I entered the fourth year of development, and while I hadn't burned out yet -- and Microsoft remained generously patient -- I had high hopes that this would be 'the year' the game saw release.

However, in early 2012, I took a hard look at the project, and while I could finish the game by the end of the year, I would have to wait until 2013 to avoid the holiday onslaught. I had already sacrificed enough of the last three years from my family (again, with hardly any days off), and I didn't want to put them through a fourth.

Microsoft internally had high hopes for the game, and my producer arranged to have a demo shown at PAX East in Boston. This was incredibly generous of them, as they handled the booth, leaving me only to cover my own accommodations. Considering I wasn't swimming in money, I was thankful for the opportunity.

PAX arrived, and everything changed in the span of about 48 hours. I'd expected a small showing, a few interested fans, and a lot of people passing by my booth to play the other XBLA titles that were being prepped for release in the coming weeks. We started with a moderate showing -- but then Giant Bomb swung by and mentioned the game at their PAX panel. Then Mike Krahulik from Penny Arcade stopped by to check out the game. Then Cliff Bleszinski. It wasn't long before we had lines over an hour long to play the game.

Needless to say, after spending so long on the game, I'd lost nearly all objectivity. But seeing so many people playing and enjoying the game was one of the most validating moments of the game's development for me. Also, after working with him for over a year via Steam Chat by that point, I finally got to meet my co-writer, Alex Kain, in person. Between that and hanging out with my partners at Microsoft, it was a fantastic show.

Less than a week after returning from PAX, Microsoft suggested I pursue a Summer of Arcade release. How could I say no?

What Went Wrong

1. The Most Difficult Three Months of My Life

After a lot of back and forth with Microsoft, my family, and a whole lot of prayer, I said yes to Summer of Arcade. I would have to take an already massively difficult eight to 10 months of development and cram it into three. I knew I would see very little of my family during that period (despite working from home), including my newborn daughter, due just two months later.

Much of what happened after that is a blur. I was already used to working seven days a week, but now those turned into nearly 20 hour workdays. I couldn't go to bed saying "I'll finish that tomorrow" because tomorrow would bring a new set of challenges. I'm a pretty "got it together" kind of guy, but I broke down a number of times. If it wasn't for my family literally placing food between me and my monitors, I wouldn't have eaten. The days where I realized I hadn't stepped out of the house and looked at the sky for over two weeks made me realize how crazy this all was.

I can hardly remember cranking out all the cutscenes, wrapping up the remaining enemies, and populating the rest of the world during those hectic weeks. I have no idea how I was able to rewrite several massive systems -- including one to resolve a bug that threatened to cut all the voice over from the game -- just days before certification. I consider myself a man of faith, and it was certainly tested during those dark hours.

And it wasn't exactly a walk in the park for my collaborators. On top of working on multiple projects themselves, we were all caught off guard by the accelerated schedule. HyperDuck produced music and sound at an insane pace, Toon Platoon was recording and editing hundreds of lines across 40 actors seemingly overnight, and Alex and I rushed on last-minute changes to the script to accommodate the actors and to lock it down for localization.

Looking back, I honestly can't explain how I got it done. Everyone on the inside knows how deathly close we made it, from nearly cutting all dialogue and cutscenes, to issues in certification and localization -- the list goes on.

2. Biting the Bullet and Axing Features

On the subject of trimming content, Dust: AET was originally envisioned as a much larger game than it ended up being. Once I had the core mechanics down, I made the tough decision to prune my initial concept. There were actually a lot more non-combative plans, such as owning property, farming, fishing, and so on. I'd spent a lot of time planning these features and, perhaps even more problematically, envisioning them naturally as parts of the game in my head. For the longest time, Dust: AET needed these disparate components to be Dust: AET.

Most of these grander concepts were pulled simply out of necessity. It's immensely hard parting with a concept -- any concept -- that you see adding value to your dream game, but the reality of being one man and really wanting to get the game done before the universe imploded weighed heavily on my mind.

One idea, however, stuck around longer than any other: the concept of building up a small town using your amassed wealth, similar to the town-building mechanics seen in games like the latter Assassin's Creed titles. This town was where your rescued "friends" would live, and new building types would provide passive bonuses to you on your adventure. Remnants of these ideas persist in some of the materials you acquire.

Alex: This was still on Dean's plate when I came onto the project in 2011, and at first it sounded like an awesome idea. First of all, it served as a money sink, which is always helpful when you can grind enemies and wealth. Secondly, it gave players a kind of third "progression pillar", in addition to advancing the storyline and their own stats, giving players something else to build up. Unfortunately, as Dean mentioned above, he's just one guy, and Dust: AET was still far from complete.

I suggested that Dean reconsider the "build your own village" concept, but I could tell he had already crossed it out of his own internal design documentation. Once in a while he would wistfully refer to it and ponder whether he could squeeze it in, even in a less-robust state, but the realities of game development hit hard. There would be sacrifices and cuts, and the early feature creep that represented the fun and experimental beginnings of the project were long behind us.

3. Overcomplicating the Finale

Alex: Towards the end of 2011, Dust: AET was beginning to come together. It was impressive seeing the levels going up screen-by-screen, but a rather large problem was looming in the background this whole time: the story was nowhere near finished.

In actuality, the outline Dean had laid out called for an entirely new sixth chapter -- a massive third act that took the player to brand new locations fighting against a new main antagonist and changing the entire focus of the storyline. Length-wise, this finale would have tacked on another couple hours of gameplay time, which equated to another several months of development time.

In the interest of getting the game done, Dean and I resolved to cut this final section of the game and tighten up what we had, promoting General Gaius up to main antagonist and centering the game around his campaign. While this sounded great on paper, it meant a lot of late-night, multi-hour conversations with Dean where we hashed out numerous alternate story possibilities. How would we tie the caverns, meadows, and mountains into the new Gaius plotline? How would we be able to establish Gaius as a villain when you don't actually meet him until the end of the game?

For Dean, the problem was more about cutting content that he had already worked on. When you're on a team, cutting content is a fact of life. When you're one guy, every single asset you create is important. The area had already been laid onto the world map, the music had already been written, and Dean had spent years envisioning the ending in his head. Then I came in and politely (sort of) threw that out the window.

In the end, Dean ended up agreeing with my decision to cut the third act and consolidate the story we had. It was hard to part with the mysterious final villain, but the game ended up a lot tighter, and the story felt much more satisfying ending where it did.


Article Start Previous Page 3 of 4 Next

Related Jobs

Treyarch / Activision
Treyarch / Activision — Santa Monica, California, United States
[04.19.14]

Associate Art Director - Treyarch
Treyarch / Activision
Treyarch / Activision — Santa Monica, California, United States
[04.19.14]

Associate Animator (temporary) - Treyarch
Activision Publishing
Activision Publishing — Santa Monica, California, United States
[04.19.14]

Executive Producer-Skylanders
Activision Publishing
Activision Publishing — Santa Monica, California, United States
[04.19.14]

Director, Central User Testing






Comments


Thomas Happ
profile image
What I have always wondered is, did Microsoft provide any sort of cash advance with which to support yourself, or was it all out of pocket?

Thanks for the awesomely detailed postmortem, Dean. You're an inspiration!!

Ramon Carroll
profile image
Wow, this was a really good read. Thank you so much for sharing this, Dean.

Alfie Parthum
profile image
Dean, when I was a much younger man, I used to post on your forums. I really wanted to know how it was done! Even after seeing so much of the magic in its unfinished state, even knowing how it’s made, the level of craftsmanship and creativity present in your art still never fails to amaze me. This postmortem was also enlightening.

I’m happy to hear you have been able to apply your particular brand of assiduity to game development as well, and that your family life is still great. Thanks for sharing.

Muir Freeland
profile image
This is a great postmortem, and this is a really beautiful-looking game.

Josh Mulanax
profile image
Fantastic write up Dean - I know I'm not alone when I say that I hope to see more games from you in the future!

K Gadd
profile image
Thanks for sharing a postmortem, Dean! Love the amount of detail in here.

Per Micael Nyberg
profile image
Dean, Thank you for sharing your difficult but ultimately rewarding and life-altering journey with us. Great read!

Talat Fakhri
profile image
The story is sheer inspiration. The process of making the game itself sounded like a hardcore game.

Lars Doucet
profile image
What I think is really cool about this story, is how Dean wasn't afraid to learn new skills and techniques out of his safety zone, and created something brilliant.

Alexei Baboulevitch
profile image
Amazing work, but it worries me that this is yet another indie game where the creator nearly tore himself apart trying to put it together. I'd love to know — is it really impossible to create a game with similar quality while maintaining a healthy five-day work week? I'd love to make a game as personal as this some day, but I don't know if I could sacrifice my health and social life for it.

On another note, this is an incredible achievement for someone who didn't know how to program getting into it. I'm a programmer and I know I'd have a lot of difficulty with some of these problems.

Lars Doucet
profile image
I've done alright keeping a regular work schedule with my own indie projects, but whether it's of "similar quality" is an exercise best left to the reader. I think it's possible to maintain work-life balance, but there's also just an undeniable element of risk involved.

Ramon Carroll
profile image
I think the key question to ask is: Why do we do what we do? Once a person resolves that question himself/herself, then one can determine whether an endeavor is worth his/her time.

Hint: Wealth and fame only satisfy for a season. Autonomy, mastery, and purpose are forever.

WILLIAM TAYLOR
profile image
You could do it without the sacrifice but remember that it took this guy 3.5 years working 7 days a week. At a leisurely pace it's probably going to take you significantly longer than that.

On a related note though, this was a passion project for him. Do what you do but if you're not willing to make some sacrifices for it you could probably find a significantly less stressful hobby to get into.

Kain Shin
profile image
The game has so much love put into it, and it really shows in just about every detail.

Keith Thomson
profile image
This sounds like exactly the sort of game I would want, hopefully it will come out on other platforms in the future. Given the steep memory requirements, I can only think of 2 other platforms it would work on though.

Taure Anthony
profile image
Easily one of the best reads on here, thanks for talking the time. The game looks epic.

Andrew Sum
profile image
This is a fantastic article. Thank you so much for sharing. That voice over problem you ran into does really sound like a nightmare - realizing that something you put so much effort into would simply have to be cut. But I'm so glad you managed to figure it out, and now you've got a great triumph to tell! Very inspirational to all of us who have run into similar project-breaking problems.


none
 
Comment: