Contents
Fountain of Scribbles: 5th Cell's Jeremiah Slaczka Speaks
 
 
Printer-Friendly VersionPrinter-Friendly Version
 
Latest News
spacer View All spacer
 
February 9, 2010
 
Analysts: EA On The Right Track At Last
 
E3 2010 Registration Opens As Major Exhibitors Confirmed
 
Ubisoft Q3 Sales Edge Down, As It Ramps Up Big Franchises
spacer
Latest Jobs
spacer View All     Post a Job     RSS spacer
 
February 9, 2010
 
Roblox
Apple Game Engineer - Kids' Virtual World
 
Roblox
Senior Web Engineer (front-end)
 
Ubisoft San Francisco
Core Engineer
 
Ubisoft San Francisco
Gameplay Engineer
 
Vicarious Visions / Activision
Audio Programmer
 
Flashpoint Academy
Game Development and Animation Teachers
 
Rockstar North
Senior Graphics Programmer
 
Ubisoft San Francisco
Network Engineer
spacer
Latest Features
spacer View All spacer
 
February 9, 2010
 
arrow Television, Meet Games
 
arrow Two Halves, Together: Patrick Gilmore On Double Helix [1]
 
arrow The Road To Hell: The Creative Direction of Dante's Inferno [20]
 
arrow The Sensible Side of Immersion [11]
 
arrow Jumpstarting Your Creativity [6]
 
arrow Truth in Game Design [49]
 
arrow Postmortem: Vicious Cycle's Matt Hazard: Blood Bath and Beyond [4]
 
arrow Developers React: The iPad's Future [16]
spacer
Latest Blogs
spacer View All     Post     RSS spacer
 
February 9, 2010
 
Lineage 2 Interview - 'Freya Update Is Just a Beginning' - Pt.2
 
Fixing the GDC 2010 Schedule Builder [1]
 
Swashbuckling for Landlubbers: Why you may already be encouraging piracy! [19]
spacer
About
spacer News Director:
Leigh Alexander
Features Director:
Christian Nutt
Editor At Large:
Chris Remo
Advertising:
John 'Malik' Watson
Recruitment/Education:
Gina Gross
 
Feature Submissions
Features
  Fountain of Scribbles: 5th Cell's Jeremiah Slaczka Speaks
by Brandon Sheffield
8 comments
Share RSS
 
 
October 9, 2009 Article Start Page 1 of 5 Next
 

Scribblenauts entered E3 as an unknown and transformed into a must-have game on the back of the buzz generated by its showing there. Four months later, it's a tentpole Nintendo DS game that gamers everywhere are familiar with.

It's the third Nintendo DS game from developer 5th Cell, which built its expertise developing mobile titles but has, more recently, pursued a strategy of making original DS IP. Where did that idea come from? And what is the strategy of the 5th Cell, growing its business on the back of unconventional hits like Scribblenauts?

Advertisement

Here, co-founder Jeremiah Slaczka lays it all out for Gamasutra, including the company's future plans -- such as Xbox Live Arcade development -- and why he refused to create the SpongeBob and Wii versions of Drawn to Life.

How did this Scribblenauts idea come to be? To me, it sounds like the kind of thing that someone would be like, "Wouldn't it be cool if?" "Yeah, but that's too hard." "Oh well."

Jeremiah Slaczka: The cool thing is after Drawn to Life, we had a couple more pitches I wanted to do. One was Lock's Quest. And then I had another idea about writing.

What if you could write Mad Lib style, where you could write sentences, and they would come to life in the top screen? I would say, "The dog is walking through the forest," and the dog would pop down and the forest, and he would walk through. I thought to myself, "That's a really cool idea."

The problem is there's no gameplay. It was crazy -- I actually had a dream. I never dream of video game ideas. But I had a dream where I was in this Aztec temple, and you go in this room. In every room, there'd be these weird puzzles. In one there were three paintings hanging on the wall and you have to make them straight. And then you get down and open the portal to the next room.

I thought, "This is a really cool idea for a game, but it doesn't have a hook, and there's no replayability." I was kind of working on that and seeing where that would go, like, maybe that would fit on Wii. Maybe that would fit on DS. I don't know. Then I though, "Wait. What if we take the writing idea and slam it with the puzzle idea, and all of the sudden you've got instant replayability because you could write anything."

Then I talked to Marius, our technical director, and he was like, "Yeah, dude, this is awesome. Let's do it." And he was really pumped. He was the one that actually loved the writing. Before that I didn't know where it was going. It was boring at the moment. It's wasn't a game. It was just an idea.

A lot of people actually at 5th Cell were like, "This can't be done. And even halfway through development, people at 5th Cell said, "Dude, it's not happening." And we just had to say, "Yes, it is. Don't worry. I've got it, me and Marius. We see the vision. We know exactly where it's going."

In traditional video games, you have level one, and then there are enemies for level one, and then there are the platforms or whatever there is for level one. And like you make it, you polish it, then you go on, right? In this, in level one, you can write anything. So the second the bear doesn't work or the anvil isn't heavy, people will go, "What the heck? This game sucks. I don't understand."

So, we had to get everything in before level one could actually work, so that was about 80 percent of the development, just doing that. Then we got about 80 percent, and then we actually showed publishers and stuff. Because before that, they couldn't really demo it. "Oh, this is a cool idea, but nothing works."

It seems like there's obviously a huge top end on the planning side, because you have just like a big box of everything to draw from immediately. I could imagine it being difficult to see that actually coming together.

JS: The second it all came together, it was like a light switch. Bang, everything works. It's like, "Dude, this is now fun."

 
Article Start Page 1 of 5 Next
 
Comments

Josh Milewski
profile image
I think I'd really love to get an internship at 5TH Cell. I mean, I've got to do an internship or some kind of research at school in order to get my CS degree (it's a graduation requirement), so I'm planning on trying to get an internship for next summer, but I'd really really like to do one in game development.

And the spirit of 5TH Cell's games and of their attitude about their own work is just so.. good.

Ah man, it's like a dream, haha.

Stephen Northcott
profile image
Interesting read. I think people should watch Zero Punctuation's review as well as read this.

Jeffrey Parsons
profile image
I don't particularly like Scribblenauts, but I completely fail to understand how Ben Croshaw's opinion of it matters. I realize he has picked up a crowd of people who like his tiresome, repetitive, smug, world-weary-cynic ranting, but those who realize he's just another failed game designer with a huuuuuge chip on his shoulder tuned out of his monochromatic, kiddie-pool depth schtick a while ago.

Stephen Northcott
profile image
Croshaw is indeed "tiresome, repetitive, smug", as you say.
But he's also pretty accurate at picking out a game's problems most of the time, and he doesn't base his views on the advertising inches the publisher has bought from him. It also doesn't take genius to spot obvious flaws, it has to be said. :)

My point was that Scribblenauts is flawed. Great idea. Badly implemented. I don't get any feeling that the guys behind Scribblenauts in any way get that the game has these glaring flaws, which is easy to miss / overlook when you sell bucket loads of a product. So I personally think Croshaw's comments are a fair rebuttal to what is also quite a "tiresome, repetitive, smug" interview above. :)

Joe Tringali
profile image
>I don't get any feeling that the guys behind Scribblenauts in any way get that the game has these glaring flaws

Trust me, we follow all reviews and understand the game wasn't perfect. As Jeremiah said in the interview, one of our biggest gripes is lack of development time to move our stuff from a 80s metacritic average into the 90's. That 10 points is all polish.

Alec Shobin
profile image
Great to see someone from the studio on these boards! Thanks for sharing your input. It's interesting that you point to the Metacritic review score as the definitive rating of your games... But I guess that's the best tool we have for determining the public's affinity towards a product.

Jeffrey Parsons
profile image
"My point was that Scribblenauts is flawed. Great idea. Badly implemented"

This may be the case - liking it, like Croshaw's act, is a matter of personal taste. And I'm certainly no fan of the tremendous hype that seems to accompany certain games from the indie sphere.

But the double-edged sword of game development seems odd to me. On the one hand we have people complaining that nothing new is tried. On the other we have people who complain endlessly when something new is tried, but it isn't pitch perfect.

I'm not a fan of Scribblenauts, but I wouldn't take a stance advising people not to buy it. It's cheap, it's portable, and it has some appeal.

Stephen Northcott
profile image
@Joe : Appreciate the reply. And good to know that you're tracking these things. :) I do love your concept.

@Jeffrey : Oh, I actually agree with you. I hate the rinse - repeat - churn out format of the big publishers. And applaud anyone who tries something new, regardless of it's commercial success or not. And yes I guess it seems harsh that when someone does something original and then misses the mark a bit that we all jump on them. But I think developers would rather have honest feedback than fawning admiration. Well, I know I certainly would rather it that way.

My criticism was of the implementation, not the concept (which is awesome).
I certainly did not advise people not to buy it. I think anyone reading here is very likely to make their own mind up regardless of any comment made here. So comments I make are based on the premise that we're all professionals and as such don't need to embellish our words with twinkly bits to mind people's egos.

My only hope is that the concept gets refined and implemented better in a revision or new release, and my comments were because I feel the game is being sold on the concept whereas the implementation disappoints somewhat. I say these things because I care about the Art, not the publisher - to be perfectly frank.

If you take a look at the implementation that people behind PixelJunk put into their ideas I would say that is a good yard arm to measure your attempt to hit the concept / implementation sweet spot. :)



none
 
Comment:
 


Submit Comment