Upon its initial announcement, Gearbox Software's upcoming Borderlands
drew heavy comparisons to id Software's Rage
, with its FPS/driving hybrid gameplay and desolate landscapes -- comparisons that amused producer Simon Hurley, who hypothesized "convergent evolution
The reveal of the game's extensive weapon system, which uses a procedural system to generate some 650,000 possible pieces of equipment for players to find, has also been seen as reminiscent of Blizzard's classic hack-and-loot extravaganza Diablo
It's been in development for about two and a half years, but the idea has been germinating at Gearbox for much longer, Hurley tells Gamasutra -- and simply defining it in terms of other games is selling it short.
"It's an idea that several of us have been throwing around for quite a while, even when we were working back on Halo
for PC, and, certainly, doing Brothers in Arms
," he explains. "More and more people got on board with it, and we started looking at, 'When do we launch our second IP?'
"Brothers in Arms
was very well-established as a franchise, and we wanted to build a new one. This was the one that most people were excited about, so we went ahead and did it, and a lot of those core people came."
He points out that, though Borderlands
has received a lot of attention for its Diablo
-esque weapon and loot system, the game is not randomly generated from a level design standpoint like Diablo
"It's going to be a very crafted experience," he said. "You know, when you start throwing the word out
'randomization' into a game, people get an idea that it's going to be, 'Who knows what'll happen?' We're doing a very crafted experience, and there are certain elements of it that are randomized, but we try and keep that within a core gameplay structure."
Comparisons between the two games are more appropriate when it comes to Borderlands
' take on four-player co-op play: "We're all big fans of co-op gameplay, so we said, 'Let's build for co-op from the ground up.' Say I'm halfway through the main campaign, and I jump into your new game."
"I can take my character into your game, with all of my leveling and skills and weapons. I can find new weapons in your game; I can trade you weapons I have; we can continue playing, and then I can take that character back into my game and continue going with all that equipment intact. The persistent character is core to the title."
Hurley is confident that Borderlands
as a complete title will be plenty unique. Its current state is actually the result of great deal of iteration, rather than a deliberate attempt to fuse a number of existing game concepts.
"We had some different times during the development of the project, where we've said, 'We think we're going to be going in this direction,' and once we get a thing in place, we're said, 'Wow! That's even better!' he recalled. "It comes out with an iterative game design, but it gets us to a superior quality product."