| E Zachary Knight |
|
|
I can certainly see Ubisoft's reasoning here. The guy dismissed it without prejudice. So he is essentially a ticking time bomb that Ubisoft wants dealt with now rather than at or after launch of AC3.
|
|
|
| Bryan Ferris |
|
|
Good; they created a great series, and they don't deserve having someone claiming they stole it. There are similarities between AC and the author's work, but no where near enough to be able to say that AC stole it form him.
|
|
|
| R Hawley |
|
|
I haven't read the authors books nor played AC3 so I couldn't comment on how similar they are. The notion that ideas are somehow unique discrete entities that have not been influence by anything else in our culture is utter BS though.
Remember that DreamWorks movie "The Island"? They settled with screenwriter of the 1979 movie "Clonus". Was he was right to take it to court? Did DreamWorks deserve to practically re-make a B movie without asking the original author? I don't know. |
|
|
| Stewart Trezise |
|
The author's book and the Assassin's Creed franchise may share some fundamental similarities, but I think it's been greatly understated that Ubisoft's creative team have designed an enormous world, teaming with interesting characters, beautiful historic environments and must have undergone some very painful research to imbue the games with the level of detail and historical references that make the games such a wonderful experience.
The elements that the author claims ownership of, namely the reliving of ancestral memories (essentially time travel), and an 'illuminati'-esque conspiracy are such a small component of the work that they have done, that they are almost insignificant by comparison. It's such a shame that one of the better development teams still committed to bringing us beautifully crafted experiences, instead of crudely following trends and going through the motions to make money, can have their work slandered like this. I'm sure it won't slow them down though, it'd take more than this to tarnish the AC brand. Sorry for the long-winded comment. |
|
|
More: Console/PC, Business/Marketing, Exclusive