Gamasutra: The Art & Business of Making Gamesspacer
View All     RSS
October 20, 2014
arrowPress Releases
October 20, 2014
PR Newswire
View All

If you enjoy reading this site, you might also want to check out these UBM Tech sites:

Bringing XCOM back to life Exclusive
September 26, 2012 | By Colin Campbell

September 26, 2012 | By Colin Campbell
More: Console/PC, Design, Exclusive, Video

When Firaxis took on the job of re-imagining the strategy game XCOM for the 21st century, it may have accepted one of the toughest tasks of the year. The franchise was almost worshipped as a beacon of all that was great about games in the early 1990s, and now publisher 2K Games and two of its studios are trying to turn that nostalgia into something current and tangible.

Leading up to release, XCOM: Enemy Unknown (a PC and console counterpart to 2K Marin's upcoming tactical shooter XCOM) has garnered positive coverage, both from journalists familiar with the original as well as those of a younger generation; those who are less inclined to be impressed by the nostalgic glow of the distant past.

XCOM: Enemy Unknown came with some creative and design challenges, as producer Garth DeAngelis explained to me in a recent interview.

One problem has been the need to catch up on 20 years worth of design evolution. In other genres outside of turn-based strategy, there has been a rapid and fierce battle of annual oneupmanship going on. Although turn-based strategy has not been entirely ignored this past two decades, it has not faced the same sort of severe tests of market-based adaptation.

DeAngelis said, "If you look at it FPSes and the action genre in the last 20 years, there's certainly a timeline where there's a good amount of releases every single year. Every month, where you can say, 'This game did something different. It pushed the genre in a new direction.' In turn-based and strategy games there's a huge gap."

He added, "Our source material has been the original XCOM: UFO Defense, but we also have guys who worked on The Elder Scrolls series or the Fallout series. They love action games. So a lot of these other ideas trickle into the design and the feel of the game from these other genres that also put their stamp on the turn-based genre."

XCOM: Enemy Unknown gives the player strategic control of a military agency seeking to thwart an alien invasion. But the tactical gameplay is about forming elite squads of players, and pitting them against enemies, taking advantage of tactical maneuvers, individual unit strengths and terrain.

One of the best aspects of XCOM: Enemy Unknown is the constant fear and danger of losing key personnel. Death is permanent in this game, so focusing too many resources into too few units is generally a bad idea, and this can bring frustration to the player.

DeAngelis explained, "You could get into a death spiral in the original game, where you could lose some vital people and you're just playing until you lost the game. We wanted to avoid that. We felt like that was something that wasn't necessarily fun in the original. So we did some things to change that."

He added, "There are some mechanics in place that will encourage you, and in some cases force you, to use other players, because your soldiers can get fatigued. They can get wounded. You can't just back to back to back level up four to six guys and only use them. You're going to have an A squad, a B squad, a C squad." In some respects, it's a little like FIFA-tactics, which punishes the player who pours all resources onto the field, and keeps a very weak bench of substitutes.

But ultimately the game's biggest inspiration is the original. DeAngelis said, "If you look at everything from the art style to the alien design of the original XCOM, you have a lot of classic sci-fi elements. We didn't want to stray too far from that. It was tempting, at a few points in development, to say, 'Okay, let's look at what these other creative people are doing'. Whether it's in movies or books or things like District 9, which were really impactful at the time. Let's look at what they're doing and see what's different and maybe we can get some inspiration and put that into XCOM.

"But we really wanted to stay true to the original, for a lot of reasons. When you play our game, there certainly is this external narrative of aliens invasion, but the more impactful part of our game is the internal narrative. To support that internal narrative, you need this foundation, this framework. Part of the magic of the internal narrative of XCOM is that it's a different story every time, but you're giving them this framework that enables the player to use their imagination to tell their own story. We really wanted to leverage that. That's what the original XCOM did, and we're trying to rekindle the magic of that."

Related Jobs

Rumble Entertainment, Inc.
Rumble Entertainment, Inc. — San Mateo, California, United States

Lead Designer/Creative Director
Nintendo of America Inc.
Nintendo of America Inc. — Redmond, Washington, United States

Visual Development Artist
Filament Games LLC
Filament Games LLC — Madison, Wisconsin, United States

Web & Interaction Designer
Digital Extremes
Digital Extremes — LONDON, Ontario, Canada



Maria Jayne
profile image
I quite liked the demo, despite it was obviously aimed at people who had never played an Xcom game, it still seemed to capture the flavor of the original. I would have liked the PC interface a bit more PC, they talked up the dedicated PC ui but it just felt like it was for console with some alternate key binds to me.

I'm sure there will be plenty of "true fans" who played it which have nothing positive to say but as an original Xcom player who finished it, this one seems to be on the right track.

Michael Rooney
profile image
I really wish they would have let you play one more level. The demo level was so short and so easy :(

Ali Afshari
profile image
I can't wait. Borderlands 2, Assassin's Creed 3, AC: Liberation, Sleeping Dogs, Hitman: Absolution, Dishonored, on top of a 44 game backlog...I will definitely need to carve out time for some XCOM!!!!

Jeremy Reaban
profile image
It's kind of sad that the original creators of X-com have mostly been reduced to making handheld games.

Carl Chavez
profile image
It might have been sad if Shadow Wars was bad, but it was actually kind of good. Rebelstar Command was good, too.

Harlan Sumgui
profile image
sad? why? more creative freedom, less pressure, less crunch time, growing's not a bad segment to be in at all. In fact, it is arguably a better segment to be in unless you're Vonderhaar or Anthony making mad cash on a big franchise.

Robert Swift
profile image
The new XCOM reminded me that many 'old school' games had a specific 'simulation' approach.

In the original XCOM the whole alien invasion was 'simulated'. The aliens first sent scouts and conducted expirements, then established a base which also need supply ships (by tracking them you could locate an alien base), ... . Environment was simulated in the sense that all maps were dynamically generated, based on the location and time of day. Soldiers gained the skills which they used during a mission, like carrying stuff, shooting, throwing grenades, ... .

A lot of these mechanics seem to have been cut down a bit (e.g. simplified decision where to send your only team, soldier class, edited maps which also seem to be quite small, ...)

I still liked the demo (it was surely too short and with too much hand holding) but would have liked to see more of the 'simulation' approach of the original preserved.

Harlan Sumgui
profile image
It's [i]all[/i] about fun today in mainstream single player development. And fun can only be had when there is a very small learning curve, winning is guaranteed, and there is no frustration.

august clark
profile image
So true Harlan, that Dark Souls game was a total failure. Did it sell more than 6 copies?

Tomi Vesanen
profile image
Try the new XCom on Classic Ironman difficulty and come back and tell us how "winning is guaranteed" again.