Gamasutra: The Art & Business of Making Gamesspacer
View All     RSS
October 26, 2014
arrowPress Releases
October 26, 2014
PR Newswire
View All

If you enjoy reading this site, you might also want to check out these UBM Tech sites:

A film director gets video games right in Starbreeze's Brothers Exclusive
A film director gets video games right in Starbreeze's  Brothers
August 9, 2013 | By Mike Rose

August 9, 2013 | By Mike Rose
More: Console/PC, Business/Marketing, Exclusive

"The thing is with Brothers, we had some game designs, and we ended up having arguments, because people said to me 'This is not how you're supposed to do games.' But I was absolutely sure that this was going to be a really great game. No-one could stop me, I felt so confident."

Josef Fares is not your typical video game designer -- he's actually a top Swedish film director by trade. However, back in 2011 Fares brought an idea for a video game concept to Starbreeze Studios, and the studio was well and truly convinced.

Fares' first foray into the world of video games launched earlier this week. Brothers: A Tale of Two Sons is a unique puzzle game, in which players control two boys via each of the separate analogue sticks on their Xbox 360 controller.

The film director turned game director has some rather different and exciting ideas about how games should be made.

"I got the chance to make this prototype, and I think because I have a film background - I think when people have tried to make a game before coming from [my background], they're not interested in games," he tells me. "They don't know what games are about."

"So for me, I was trying to do something different. I feel that games as a media is such an unexplored area. For me, I was coming from a different prespective."

Take the language that the game's inhabitants speak, for example. It's a completely made up mother tongue, and you aren't provided with any subtitles at all. Essentially you have no idea what the people in the game are saying to each other.

"The language was important for me," he notes. "I mean, don't get me wrong, I appreciate games like Heavy Rain and The Walking Dead, but I think they are too close to movie experiences. For me, it was the interactivity that was important, and also how the player interprets the story."

"That's one of the reasons that the language is made up," he continues. "So that you can put in your own thoughts and decide what they say. You can read the body language, how they talk, stuff like that - it's all for the player to be part of everything, even the short cutscenes we have in the game. That's the main reason why it's a made up language."

This concept extends further -- the game contains no text, and no explanations, other than a initial hint about the controls. Throughout play you're forced to work out exactly what is going on, and what you're meant to be doing.

"That's important," says Fares. "It's really up to the player to interact and get a feel for how the brothers are, and what their personalities are."

"Now that the game is out, we're seeing that people are getting the story. You don't really understand anything that the characters say, yet you can kind of feel it. It's more interactive, and you get to know these brothers more, and what's going on with them."

What's really interesting is how this leads to the player creating their own narrative. For example, when I played the game, I found myself moving the older brother in front of the younger brother. There's absolutely no real reason to do this, but rather, it silently became part of my own narrative for the game.

brothers 1.jpg"We have seen some players do that because it comes kind of naturally," Fares offers. "They feel that the big brother is responsible. It's exactly those sorts of reactions that I like, when players input their own sort of idea of what's going on, and even have their own idea of what sort of relationship they have."

"This is all good," he says. It's part of the interactivity, not only to the gameplay, but also to the story. I'm glad that people are doing that."

Not playing by the rules

At one point during our chat, I questioned whether Fares had considered adding a multiplayer co-operative mode to the game, in which two players could take control of each of the brothers and work together. Before I'd even got the question out, Fares was shouting "No no no!"

"That is absolutely out of the question," he says. "It's something that people have been asking me all the time, from the publisher and everything, but I've always said it is impossible. It's never going to happen."

"I remember the first time we brought the game to Microsoft, and they said that to me," he adds. "But the idea is that you actually connect - left hand is big brother, right hand is little brother. Players will understand once they've played all the way through the game why it is important to keep the brothers on each hand."

It's the way in which the puzzles have been designed that stops co-op ever being a possibility for Brothers, too.

"Many of the puzzles are made so that it's actually more comfortable to control with one controller," he says. "It's like tying your shoelaces - if you're going to tie it with someone else, it's going to feel strange, but when you tie it alone, you're more comfortable. That's the idea. I mean, most of the puzzles in Brothers are designed in that way, so you feel more comfortable controlling it yourself."

brothers 2.jpgThe variety in the puzzles was also a sticking point for Fares, and something that caused arguments. Coming from a film industry background, Fares found that many modern games extend the playtime by simply repeating the same old mechanics and set pieces over and over again.

"Variety in the game mechanics was extremely important," he tells me. One thing I get tired with in games is when they reuse the same mechanic all the time. The idea with Brothers was to change it all the time."

"Of course, that takes a lot of content to work, with code and animation and everything, but for me it was very important to keep the experience varied, instead of just reusing stuff. I know some people said the game is a bit short, but you know, we could have easily made a game that's 10 hours long, and reused everything. But for me, it's a fairy tale experience, and you should experience something once only, and then not again."

It sounds like this will not be Fares' only video game venture. The director is keen to explore more ideas, and use his background to create even more different game experiences.

"I really felt like, and I still really feel, like I have a lot of ideas for games that I hope I can make in the future," he says.

Related Jobs

Digital Extremes
Digital Extremes — London, Ontario, Canada

Character Artist
Digital Extremes
Digital Extremes — London, Ontario, Canada

Sound Designer
Disruptor Beam, Inc.
Disruptor Beam, Inc. — Framingham, Massachusetts, United States

Lead 3D Artist
Red 5 Studios
Red 5 Studios — Orange County, California, United States

Graphics Programmer


Daniel Backteman
profile image
I was really suspicious of Josef Fares when this was revealed years ago. He spoke grand about how he's really passionate about games, how being a film director gave him a different view and that they were going to do something unique. Pretty much the same thing everyone says.

In the end, even after all the time where there wasn't any info, it seems to have turned out well! An actually unusual game with a lot of thought into it which shows.

Anyway, kudos to Josef and the people at Starbreeze for starting and finishing this. I absolutely hope that this sells well, and either way you've made me proud. I'm buying a copy when it's out on Steam.

So, does this mean that you're coming back to making oddball cult films again, or are you staying in game development?

Caleb Garner
profile image
it seems kinda silly to make it seem like a film maker can't do games.. i mean i'm pretty sure there are a LOT of developers who were something else before they did games.. "(insert your prior job) gets games right".

Plenty of "game developers" get games wrong.. so yea this looks like a very interesting game and mechanic. As a father of young two boys, i find it touching and a i'm really interested to see what they could do with that dynamic. the trailer seems to show some great game mechanics using this theme. Can't wait to try it

Bart Stewart
profile image
I like the sound of the ideas here. A language to learn, with no handholding? A glossary and grammar will go online immediately, of course, but even so it's an unusual idea worth trying.

I do wonder about the control scheme. Is an Xbox controller required for the PC/Steam version? Or is mouse/keyboard supported in some way that maintains the desired feel for controlling the actions of the two brothers? I went to their site; it doesn't say.

E Zachary Knight
profile image
"A language to learn, with no handholding? A glossary and grammar will go online immediately,"

That depends. If it is like Klingon or Tolkien Elvish, then yes. But if it is like Simlish, then no.

Adam Bishop
profile image
Icelandic band Sigur Ros has song lyrics written in a fictional language called Hopelandish; there used to be a section on their web site that used crowd-sourced submissions by fans to produce some sort of algorithmically generated English interpretations of what the lyrics would translate too. Could be interesting to see something like that with this game's language.

Joel Staaf Hasto
profile image
The language in the game is actually not completely made up, it is loosely based on lebanese.

Keyboard controls(no mouse) are technically supported, but quite clunky. I would highly recommend using a controller when you play this game, not just because it's smoother, but because other aspects of the game was designed with that in mind.

Michael Pianta
profile image
This sounds like a game I need to buy.

Stephanie Kyrin
profile image
I studied film before I got into/studied game development. I'd always been a gamer, and an artist, but it was always film that came first. I feel like that has always been a help and not a hindrance. Games have the unfortunate reality of still being a very young media, and is constantly being compared to it's older siblings - traditional art, film, music... film especially, and the obsession with 'cinematic' games. People forget that you can still love film, love games, want to marry the two, but not want to make Heavy Rain. I disliked Heavy Rain - as a narrative experience it was excellent. As a gaming experience... well, I don't play games so that I can shake a controller to help a fat old detective use his asthma pump, but hey, each to their own, it got rave reviews. Heavy Rain is just one way you can marry film and games, and Brothers is another - there are even more, many which haven't been tested yet. Let's embrace them all! I for one am eager to play this.

Marijn Lems
profile image
Everyone who's interested in the storytelling potential of videogames NEEDS to play this game. The way Fares and his collaborators used the game mechanics to tell the story totally blew me away.

Katarina Gyllenback
profile image
Big grats to cocky Fares!

Why make film when you can make a game?

I hope the game industry can trust more people from the film to do games in a ”not supposed way” as people with a film background truly understand narrative as a non media-specific feature, meaning, depending on the media you apply the narrative differently (books are books, films are films and games are games and need different narrative treats, which Fares has shown).

But I don’t agree with Fares that people with film background don’t like games and should be “blamed” for how games look like. So far very few people with a professional film background have been invited to the game industry and if they were, they were probably told to do a story, as the game industry understand story – as a film.

So let’s hope that more people with a professional film background will be invited to create games in a way “they aren’t supposed to be made”.

PS Josef (if you read this), maybe you're thinking about the people at the Academy of Dramatic Art as they truly fear games?