This Week in Video Game Criticism: Responding to Feedback the Vlambeer Way
This week, our partnership with game criticism site Critical Distance brings us picks from Kris Ligman on topics including critical reception to Vlambeer's Luftrausers and the sexualized violence of Metal Gear Solid 5: Ground Zeroes.
Stephanie Jennings of Ludogabble has a spoiler-filled critique of BioShock Infinite: Burial at Sea Episode 2
, which she derides as attempting to 'redeem' the core game in the worst way imaginable:
In this apparent effort to remedy a significant problem in Infinite, BaS2 has just found another way to further reduce the agency, power, and significance of Daisy and the entire black population of Columbia. In short, it's found another way to be racist.
Meanwhile, on Media Diversified, Brittney White applauds BioWare dev Manveer Heir's recent talk on inclusivity delivered at GDC, but points to some problems apparent within his own studio's titles
Digging Up the Past
Giant Bomb's Patrick Klepek has a solid breakdown of recent discussions concerning the glamorization of Nazis in Luftrausers
. Also worth reading: developer Rami Ismail's classy take on the situation
Elsewhere, on Kill Screen, Ben Meredith shares with us how games are like archaeology
Always Going Forward (Cos We Can't Find Reverse)
Storycade's Chris Klimas has an interesting bit on the rise of Twine and other parserless engines
in the Interactive Fiction community.
Over on Paste, our own Cameron Kunzelman bracingly addresses the sexualized violence of MGS V: Ground Zeroes
in the context of the series to date (content warning:
discussion of rape and brutalization):
For all of its baroqueness, the Metal Gear universe has a deceptively simple message: There is a machine bigger than any single human, and trying to conquer it or shape it to your own individual will is almost impossible. [...] The Metal Gear games present us with an augmented, nihilistic version of the phrase: War is always changing, and you can never catch up.
If war is the stand in for the designer in the Metal Gear Solid series, and war necessitates the perpetration of sexual violence against women in that universe, then there’s nothing casual about it. Instead, it signifies that Hideo Kojima has nowhere left to go.
Finally for the week, Martin Robinson is up on Eurogamer with a dose of cold, hard truth: why it may be for the best if games the likes of The Last Guardian, Half-Life 3 or Shenmue 3 never happen
And we're done! As always we greatly appreciate your submissions sent to us by email
or as mentions on Twitter
Did you know? Critical Distance is kept afloat due to generous support from readers like you! If you like what we do, please consider signing up for a small monthly donation through our Patreon