Gamasutra: The Art & Business of Making Gamesspacer
View All     RSS
September 16, 2014
arrowPress Releases
September 16, 2014
PR Newswire
View All

If you enjoy reading this site, you might also want to check out these UBM Tech sites:

MIGS 2011: Naughty Dog's Lemarchand Calls For 'Less Snark,' Reflects On  Uncharted
MIGS 2011: Naughty Dog's Lemarchand Calls For 'Less Snark,' Reflects On Uncharted
November 1, 2011 | By Kris Graft

November 1, 2011 | By Kris Graft
More: Console/PC, Art, Design

At the Gamasutra-attended Montreal International Game Summit Tuesday, Richard Lemarchand, co-lead designer on Naughty Dog's Uncharted 3: Drake's Deception, gave attendees a behind-the-scenes look at the best-selling PlayStation 3 adventure franchise, studio culture and bringing an emotional connection to video games.

Lemarchand explained how the Uncharted series, which debuted on PS3 in 2007, was built around just "a couple simple ideas."

The team at Naughty Dog wanted to give gamers a "playable game version of the summer blockbuster movies of the 1970s and 1980s," he said, while combining that with the "the spirit of pulp adventure and reinvent[ing] it for a contemporary audience."

But the Sony-owned studio, previously known best for Crash Bandicoot and Jak & Daxter, had a big challenge when making the first Uncharted title – the PS3 didn't exist yet.

So the team initially developed the game on PC, making the closest hardware guess possible. "Long story short," Lemarchand laughed, "we messed things up pretty badly. … Once we got our hands on the PS3 hardware, we were able to save it," as the studio did a full reboot of the game.

Don't Make A Fuss About Big Changes

Scrapping a large amount of previous work, and trying to fix what's broken, takes courage, Lemarchand said. "When something just isn't working, even if it's something you've been working on for a year, if it needs changing, you need not to make a fuss. You need to rip it apart and put it back together."

That kind of mindset has helped the Uncharted series gain a large audience – the first two games in the series have sold 4 million copies each, and both were hits with game reviewers.

Lemarchand cited a high-level game consultant who said some game developers create games like a software or manufacturing company, when in fact they are in the entertainment business. He said the waterfall model, used by software companies, is not particularly conducive to finding fun, or fine-tuning the gaming experience.

Instead, he said Naughty Dog doesn't have a concrete method of making games, although the studio does follow some basic rules that foster creativity and open communication amongst the 100-person team.

"At the very beginning of a project, we do lots of brainstorming," said Lemarchand. "…Then we get to work as quickly as we could implementing these ideas, and they give us fixed reference points… this is one way that making a video game is fundamentally different than making a movie."

"We don't use any kind of formal methodology," and that, Lemarchand said, gives Naughty Dog's games their unique personality.

Brutal Honesty

Everyone on the team is encouraged to give ideas and criticisms on a game, Lemarchand said. "We force ourselves to be brutally honest with each other… if something isn't up to scratch, we say so, and sometimes very bluntly."

The flat studio structure at Naughty Dog helps foster this open line of communication. "Sometimes it's very messy and chaotic, but it's very messy in a good way, because people in charge are also the ones making the game," he said.

"The bad parts of the game always, always get called by someone in the mix," Lemarchand added. "…The things that suck about the game design… either get taken out of the game, or get fixed, because all the people on the team will be beating down the door of the person responsible, every single day."

While Naughty Dog does encourage bluntness, there are some informal guidelines to internal feedback. "We must never, ever get personal, and not be too blunt – not use too many swear words," he joked. "We have this informal contract that we won't get too bent out of shape with each other, and [remember that] we're all working towards greatness."

"This culture of open communication also strengthens our team as a whole. … We become more accountable to one another, and we trust each other even more," he said. Teams that lack that trust are "prone to paralysis" – a detrimental situation, as "responding to change is the key to successful game development."

"We get [our studio culture] from the fact that the people at the top of this organization model these behaviors. … It's natural to adopt those habits. … They operate very much on the basis of 'Do as I do, not as I say.'"

Emotion In Games

Naughty Dog's Uncharted games aim to refine the art of storytelling in interactive entertainment. Lemarchand addressed a common problem with storytelling in games.

"The problem is often simply a lack of emotional connection between characters and players," he said. "…When video games are at their best, they can create deep and emotional resonances in our players."

Often video games can connect with players' intellect, " …But [games] do not connect to their hearts in quite the way that we like. I think this is an enormous wasted opportunity that robs our form of its potential power."

Lemarchand stressed that Naughty Dog's "wide linear" approach to game design and storytelling in games is not the only way to tell a story. But there is a common theme he has noticed that is hindering games' emotional potential.

"I think I understand the source of at least a part of that problem, just like for the [voice actors] who didn't get the part of Nathan Drake, we as game developers are often acting too tough and too snarky when we are making our games."

He called for a Steven Spielberg-like disruption of expectations of gender, sexual orientation, and a shattering of stereotypes in general.

"It's important that we have something to say," said Lemarchand. "… We must be in touch with our emotions and become adept at telling them in detail, with restraint, and clarity, and above all, vulnerability."

Related Jobs

Machine Zone
Machine Zone — Palo Alto, California, United States

Game Designer
BattleCry Studios
BattleCry Studios — Austin, Texas, United States

Raven Software / Activision
Raven Software / Activision — Madison, Wisconsin, United States

Lead Engineer - Raven
Respawn Entertainment
Respawn Entertainment — San Fernando Valley, California, United States

Senior Systems Designer


Jose Striedinger
profile image
Firs of all, I have great respect for Lemarchand as a game designer. I love Naughty Dog since the first Crash Bandicoot and you can see Richard passion for game design whenever he speaks. I mean, the guy (if Im not wrong) studied Philosophy at Oxford and here he is, as the Lead Game Designer of a amazing video game series. You are like a living proof that your career doesn't determine what you are going to do the rest of your life :D

I do believe that a game studio must realize that even thou they are making a software, games are not just software and that's the problem. As a computer science student I know things like security, latency, performance, usability etc are important in any software but, the thing is that those are not the most important things in a videogame. Videogames are like the best example of the great mix between engineering and art, and that's no something easy. Storytelling is something I have always liked in games, I like to get attached, to be concern about this characters, to be able to see them growth and more important, to feel that I AM the reason of that growth. Talking about emotion in games is risky, is a more artistic point of view but, definitely fascinating!

Game Developers should try to find unique game related ways to tell stories, after all this is, probably, the most dynamic entertainment out there and it has such big capabilities. Im not complaining about Uncharted blockbuster style, because after all this a business and people do want and will always want blockbuster videogames and that doesnt mean the storytelling is any "easier".

But like Richard said, videogames has an incredible potential to tell stories in their own unique way, we should find that!

Glenn Storm
profile image
A balanced and reasonable approach to tackling the impossible. Super cool!