Gamasutra is part of the Informa Tech Division of Informa PLC

This site is operated by a business or businesses owned by Informa PLC and all copyright resides with them. Informa PLC's registered office is 5 Howick Place, London SW1P 1WG. Registered in England and Wales. Number 8860726.


Gamasutra: The Art & Business of Making Gamesspacer
View All     RSS
December 15, 2019
arrowPress Releases
December 15, 2019
Games Press
View All     RSS







If you enjoy reading this site, you might also want to check out these UBM Tech sites:


 

Book Review: The Art of 3D Computer Animation and Effects, 3rd Ed


May 14, 2004
 

Oh man, is this book beautiful! Just browsing through the 500+ full-color images in The Art of 3D Computer Animation and Effects reminds me of why I entered the field of computer games and graphics in the first place.

Author Isaac Kerlow evidently loves his work, and put a lot of that love and what he knows from his position, as Director of Digital Production at the Los Angeles offices of The Walt Disney Company, into this book. (Incidentally, the company where one of my computer graphics students also now holds a position.)

It’s rare that I’ll read a book cover-to-cover twice in the same week, but to absorb the amount of detail that is Art of 3D pretty much requires it. I also kept getting distracted by the pictures. Each page carries so much eye-candy and brain-candy it’s like reading through an encyclopedia. You go in looking for one thing and wind up reading about something completely unrelated. Okay, so I’m a graphics geek and I’m geeking out on this book. It’s the kind of book you simply must geek out too. Did I mention the pictures already? All of the information and techniques presented are accompanied by a copious number of full-color images covering the last 50 years of computer animation. Art of 3D introduces many of the concepts that were pioneered in the pre-digital days and brings them right up to date.

Verdict
On Game Design cover

Title: The Art of 3D Computer Animation and Effects, 3rd edition
Author: Isaac Kerlow
Publisher: Wiley and Sons
ISBN: 0-471-43036-6
Published: July 2003
Pages: 451
Price: $60

Rating (out of 5):
5.0 out of 5 stars

Pros

  1. Eye candy! Every technique is accompanied by images from games and movies that have implemented it.

  2. More eye candy! Each technical point is illustrated with appropriate diagrams.

  3. Covers almost every subject that applies to modern computer graphics.

Cons

  1. Could use a second volume to go further in-depth on many subjects.

  2. Eye candy! The beautiful pictures can distract you from your task.

  3. Only offers a broad overview of the subject matter.

Art of 3D should ideally be read cover-to-cover, though each section stands alone and can be read in a single sitting. Much of the material is taught in a semi-tutorial style, remaining platform- and software-agnostic, but presented in a manner that lets you follow along whilst at your computer. There are only a few images from various software packages included to illustrate a particular point.

It’s quite obvious Kerlow is a visual thinker and a great believer in lists. There are lists of team breakdowns, lists of standard software packages, lists of light source types—lists for everything. He even illustrates his lists with images.

Each section opens with a summary of what will be covered, jumps right into deep end of the material with appropriate images and illustrations, and finally wraps up with a list of terminology and points covered. The list is presented as bullet points to aid you in remembering the key items that were covered. Many sections also wrap up with a “Getting Started” piece for readers who are not sure how to approach the subject.

I’ve worked with quite a few art directors and game designers (as well as other programmers) who are incredibly talented and competent in their fields, but can occasionally lack the terminology for basic things such as camera movement or types of lights, and it then falls to me to doodle very poor illustrations on a whiteboard to explain my idea visually. I’ll be referring to Art of 3D a lot more when attempting this, as the simple comic-book panels illustrate key points perfectly. It’s not often you see the concept of ray-tracing explained using a pig in a top hat, a gopher holding a beer, and a strangely drawn human holding a daiquiri with an umbrella in it. I possess an entire shelf of books on cinematography techniques, and few are as succinct or clearly illustrated as the section in Art of 3D, using a wide eyed pig holding a Martini glass to illustrate the use of differing lenses, or dangling from badly knotted string for the time-freeze (a.k.a. bullet-time) effect.

Art of 3D really covers a lot of ground for the approximately 450 pages—everything from planning, workflow, production and personnel, through modeling, texturing, and lighting, right up to rendering “hacks” that modern studios will adopt to make sure they render all of the frames within the time constraints of a production schedule.

Though Art of 3D is aimed primarily at beginning to intermediate computer graphic artists, I think that many designers, programmers, and seasoned artists could really learn a lot from this book. You would need to spend years practicing traditional animation, computer graphics, stage lighting, cinematography, and many other techniques to know even a quarter of what’s covered in this book. While Art of 3D doesn’t profess to be an encyclopedic treatment of all these subjects, it does manage to give a good grounding in the small amount of space available to each section. The techniques and terminology I teach on my DirectX graphics courses are covered in vivid detail and I’ll certainly be introducing this book as recommended reading. Expect to see the 4 th Edition of this book in a few years time with all of the great visual effects that were pioneered in the Lord of the Rings trilogy.


Related Jobs

Futureplay
Futureplay — Helsinki, Finland
[12.12.19]

Senior Game Designer
Futureplay
Futureplay — Helsinki, Finland
[12.12.19]

Senior Game Programmer
Sucker Punch Productions
Sucker Punch Productions — Bellevue, Washington, United States
[12.11.19]

Camera Designer
Deep Silver Volition
Deep Silver Volition — Champaign, Illinois, United States
[12.11.19]

UI Artist





Loading Comments

loader image