In the
article "Environmental Storytelling
Part I," I discussed the similarities and differences between
the world of 3D computer games and that of theme parks such as Disneyland.
In Part II, I would like to talk about some specific techniques used
by the designers of physical "real world" spaces and how they
might be used in the creation of immersive virtual environments.
Sub-Intuitive
Elements in Design
Years ago, while studying Commercial Illustration in San Francisco,
I had an instructor who discussed the use of "Arrows and Pathways"
in illustration. Up to that point the concept was completely unknown
to me. He used the works of N.C. Wyeth, specifically his paintings for
Treasure Island, to demonstrate how, through the use of perspective,
value, and color, the artist could
force the viewer to look where
he wanted him/her to look. Not only did N.C. Wyeth have draftsmanship
and his ability to wield a brush in his favor, but he used an underlying
structure that would draw his audience helplessly to the conclusion
that
he desired them to reach! In his example, my instructor
used Wyeth's painting of Blind Pew (Figure 1).
|
Figure
1.
Wyeth's "Blind Pew."
|
In the
painting the blind pirate is standing in the road just beyond the Admiral
Benbow Inn where he has delivered the fateful "Black Spot"
to Captain Billy Bones. In the story, Blind Pew is struck down by a
carriage on the road outside the Inn. Wyeth's painting successfully
captures the moment, immediately before Pew is hit by that same carriage.
Although the carriage does not appear in the painting, you can sense
the tension in the air. Your eye is drawn to the face of Pew and despite
his murderous reputation you have sympathy for the man as he cries out
in the night.
Looking
at the illustration, it appears to break many of the rules of design.
Pew's face is one of the smallest elements in the painting, so it's
size does not draw your attention. It is not the brightest, or darkest
element in the painting, so it is not contrast that makes you look into
his face. Even the overall muted quality of the painting proves he has
not used saturated color to draw you in. Deeper in the design of the
painting lies the secret. If you look at the elements that surround
the figure of Blind Pew, you notice that every line of perspective,
every crack in the road, and every pitch in the roof of the inn points
toward the face of Pew. Notice how the line of his cane stretches up
through his arm, and points to his face. Even his tricorn hat, blown
to the ground, acts as a giant arrow pointing to his head. Like a spiraling
drain, your eye, no matter how much it may wander will be inevitably
sucked right back to the one place the artist demands you to look.
Our class
looked at other examples of Wyeth's work as well as pieces from other
famous "Golden Age" illustrators. In every case, these artists
grabbed you by the collar and dragged your attention to those elements
that were most important to the telling of their story. Without knowing,
the viewers have handed over their will to the artist's design, and
allowed him to take them on a pre-orchestrated journey.
At that
very moment my mind was completely blown apart. It was as though I had
been introduced to color for the very first time. No longer was design
a matter of creating pretty pictures. Now I understood it to be a marvelous
tool, a slight of hand, a jujitsu trick, the power to draw an audience
deep into my design, to work my will and bring my internal vision to
an audience and let them live inside of it for awhile.
Although
I might sound a little like the BBC's Sister Wendy discussing the finer
points of art, that is not my goal. I wish to set the stage for a conversation
about the very same concepts and techniques which are available to the
designers of physical spaces, both real and virtual. Like the Arrows
and Pathways in Wyeth's paintings, the world around us is filled with
equally engaging tricks and traps that can help a designer draw his
audience deep into the story he wishes to tell!
Architectural
Archetypes
|
The trees outside
Don Carson's studio.
|
Outside
my Oregon studio is a gently rolling grass covered hill. Where the lawn
meanders to the sidewalk of an adjoining street there are two tall trees,
approximately eight feet apart, and leaning slightly away from each
other. From time to time people will walk up the hill to reach our house
from the back. When they do, they are confronted by these two trees.
Although there is an expanse of several hundred feet to either side
of the trees, many have admitted that they had a compulsion to walk
between them. Others have said that they would purposely avoid walking
through them. Either way, they were faced with a choice, and had to
act upon deep emotional responses to the natural "threshold"
created by the two trees. In many ways, they had to give into feelings
that defied their common sense and make a decision based on a more primal
part of themselves.
Like the
example of the paintings, our every day world is filled with physical
"archetypes" which force us to respond in predictable ways.
These archetypes are powerful tools that can be used to draw your audience
to experience certain "feelings" about the space you have
designed, and weave them through the story you are trying to tell.
Imagine
you have a pair of columns side by side, like our two trees, and have
placed them in an open field. It is easy to predict that any passing
hikers would find the sight of the two columns intriguing and potentially
walk over to them. In the process of examining them, they might even
walk around them several times. Now, Imagine that you add a lintel bridging
the two columns, making an archway. Now the sight becomes more intriguing,
and worthy of further investigation. Add a threshold stone to the base
of the archway and you have created an irresistible mystery. With the
addition of the threshold, you have created a door, and I defy any passersby
to continue on without passing through it.... and once passing through,
somehow feeling as though they have left one place behind and entered
a new place all together. This occurs with the knowledge that they have
not left or entered anywhere. They are still in the same field as before.
If a passing person were to have the will power to avoid walking through
the threshold, they might forever wonder what might have happened if
they had.
This is
powerful stuff. More than just a doorway, we have stumbled over a root
relationship we all have with the physical world. We may feel in control
of how we interact with our environment, but in truth we can be easily
lead to a conclusion by having our primal understanding of the physical
world played with. Now add a sign over the top of that threshold that
reads "Entrance to Hell, " or simply "Forgiveness, "
etc. and watch the needle go off the chart! You have discovered how
even the simplest architectural element can be used as a vehicle to
reinforce your story! You have added the first arrow pointing to your
inevitable conclusion!