Gamasutra: The Art & Business of Making Gamesspacer
arrowPress Releases
April 23, 2014
PR Newswire
View All





If you enjoy reading this site, you might also want to check out these UBM TechWeb sites:


Interview: The Melancholy Of Keita Takahashi
Interview: The Melancholy Of Keita Takahashi
November 4, 2009 | By Simon Parkin

November 4, 2009 | By Simon Parkin
Comments
    6 comments
More: Console/PC



Keita Takahashi sits alone, six thousand miles from home, in a damp, vacant house set within the grounds of an autumn forest somewhere in the middle of England. He wears a puffer jacket, huddled next to an electric fire for warmth.

With slow, meticulous movements he wraps a length of string around the short, rounded sword he’s fashioned from a bent coat hanger. Aside from an intermittent cough, the house is otherwise empty of all noise.

Pastel sketches are spread out on the table around him, pastoral scenes, all browns, yellows and familiar yet unidentifiable rustic blurs. Clutches of green sticky notes punctuate a white board above. On each square of paper a single word is written in all-caps English. Some are verbs: “VIEW”, “RUN”, “LIE”, ROLL”. Others are nouns: “HOLE”, “TUBE”, “GRASS”, ”SLOPE”, like a checklist for creation written into existence by a monosyllabic god.

There is no rhyme or reason to the layout. The words towards the top of the board are no more important to those at its base. They are not annotations on a ground plan map, even though Takahashi will, at some point, have to reconcile his ideas to the realities of geography and physics.

For now, the eccentric video game designer seems happy to be playing in the abstract. Giant trails of string loop around the room, tacked to the ceiling. On some, tiny plasticine models of children hang from paperclips, swinging as trapeze artists on micro-ropes that, if ever scaled up for humans to enjoy, would defy both the laws of gravity and health and safety.

I have no idea how one goes abut designing a playground but, from this random assortment of ideas and trinkets, I’m almost certain that Keita Takahashi, the enigmatic mind behind Katamari Damacy and Noby Noby Boy, is no wiser.

Making A Playground

“Obviously it’s my first attempt at park design, so I’m not sure what makes a good playground at the moment,” he tells me. “I’m just trying to work it out. What do you think makes a good playground?”

It’s been four years since Takahashi announced his desire to build a playground here in Nottingham, the location of the UK’s largest alternative video games conference, GameCity. Speaking at the event, in front of the gaming media, the admission caused a mild stir. Takahashi, a deeply atypical Japanese, has always been one to speak his mind, and his irritation at Namco Bandai’s turning Katamari in to a steamrolling brand was always played out in the public sphere.

Yet, while Takahashi studied sculpture at college, there was no way he could be termed an architect. Was this a cry for help aimed towards the suits at Namco Bandai? After all, he later admits to me he was only permitted to make Katamari Damacy because he refused to work on any other of the “boring” projects that were in development at the studio. Or was it a genuine yearning to return to the roots of play, to rediscover purity and innocence among the swings and roundabouts of youth?

In the clutter of the desk in front of him here, it’s clear that whatever the reason for the outburst, Takahashi was unprepared for his dream to become a reality. Last week, on the first day of Game City 2010, the organizers stood with Nottingham City Council to announce the commissioning of the playground on a small plot of land within the Woodthorpe Grange Park.

Alone With Pen And Paper

After the press conference, one of GameCity’s organizers drove Takahashi to the local art store where he filled his basket with crayons, stickers, pens, sheaths of paper and, of course, a coat hanger. Then they took a taxi to this room, and closed the door behind him.

It’s hard to shake the feeling its precisely this sort of largely directionless creativity, free from the constraints of financial targets, demographics and brand-building that has brought Takahashi to this unlikely nook on the other side of his world.

In answer to his deflected question about what I think makes a good playground, I suggest that I’ve always enjoyed a sense of progression, where one object leads to the next, giving the participant a sense of journey, like a playful assault course.

Takahashi doesn’t respond at first, mulling it over, perhaps masking a sneer. “If there’s a pattern embedded in the design of a park, the danger is always that all of the kids just end up doing the same stuff…” he murmurs.

It’s this sort of aimless approach to game design that frustrated some players and critics with regards to his most recent title, Nobi Nobi Boy, a game that’s difficult to articulate within the usual parameters of success and failure. And yet, this dislike of the order and rigid structure of mainstream games seems to imbue every aspect of Takahashi’s approach.

Alienated By The Industry

Indeed, it's difficult to consider this strange scene as anything but a manifestation of his disillusionment with the strict framework of the wider gaming industry. I put the question to him direct.

“I think that’s true,” he agrees. “In fact, I’ve been feeling for a few years now that I’m just not suited to the games industry. Yeah, that’s certainly been an impetus for working on the playground. You’re right.”

I suggest that perhaps Takahashi’s artistic bent makes him incompatible with the Japanese studio system, that his unwillingness to compromise vision to the business side of Namco Bandai makes him a poor candidate for a commercial video game designer. “Yes,” he answers at once. Then, earnestly: “Do you have any suggestions?”

While we talk, Takahashi is constantly busy with his hands. Having wrapped the sword with string halfway up its hilt, he then discards the idea and unwinds his efforts. He speaks in low, thoughtful tones, and his relentless reflection of my questions makes this feel more like a therapy session than an interview, though I’m not sure whose benefit it’s for.

I’m astonished by his frankness. After all, our translator, a Namco Bandai employee, is also here in the role of a chaperone. Perhaps, in asking me to propose a solution to his frustrations, he is answering the question secondhand.

To Be Independent

I collect my thoughts before suggesting that, as Japan’s games industry seems still very much based around big business, perhaps he should look abroad where he might be able to slot in more comfortably with an indie developer.

“Yes. My ideal would be to be a freelancer, working with different creatives in a far more loose structure,” he admits, smirking like I’ve passed the test. While his frankness is refreshing for a Japanese game maker, it’s hard to shake the feeling that it’s also a little petulant. Whatever his frustrations with his employer, Namco Bandai has allowed him to take 8 weeks out of the office, working on a project that they will earn nothing from, save for some mild PR. Takahashi is given a long leash. With that in mind, I ask him: why the disillusionment?

“There are two main reasons for it, I think. Firstly, I‘m just frustrated with the industry as a whole. I can’t seem to predict where it’s going, which makes me feel uncomfortable," he says. "Or maybe I just don’t like where I think it’s going. I’m not sure."

"That’s probably related to my second frustration. I just can’t perceive where the fun is in recent hit video games. I see nothing in them that resonates with me and, their success leaves me feeling confused. The things I find interesting and enjoyable just aren’t reflected in the popular games of today and, I feel like there’s not much room for my voice because of that.”

Has Takahashi ever really enjoyed video games? “Certainly. I used to enjoy the Famicom era very much. In fact, at that time I was overweight because I played so many games. But I find it hard to remember the things that moved me in my childhood games. Pretty much all I think about is based on games of the moment. To be honest, right now I find the idea of working in the physical world far more exciting than working in a virtual one. I feel like having something physical makes it easier for me to communicate what I think is fun to people. There are fewer hurdles to overcome.”

It’s impossible to not detect the melancholy in Takahashi’s demeanor. I wonder if he already has regrets about the path his life has taken him. “No. No regrets at this point. Of course, I can’t predict how I’ll feel in the future…” Maybe see how the playground turns out first, I offer. He laughs a warm, rare laugh. I ask him what makes him happy at the moment. He motions to the sword in his hand and, with a smirk, says: “Finishing this.”

So happiness for Takahashi is in helping others to find happiness, I propose? “Yes. During university I grew quite bored with sculpture, and with seeing the limits of that medium. That’s what got me looking at video games, their broader horizons and possibilities. I’ve always wanted to make things that would enable people to enjoy their lives. That’s one reason I first looked to video games, to be able to make things that people could enjoy around the world. Perhaps part of this experience is in rediscovering how I can do that in video games, by revisiting the limitations of sculpture…”

Helping Others Find Happiness

It’s dusk. We pack up and leave the house in the failing light. Standing in a nearby car park, waiting for a taxi, I ask Takahashi what games, if any, he’s playing at the moment. “Er, Noby Noby Boy on iPhone. That’s it,” he says. That smirk surfaces again and I realize he takes a certain pride in his derision towards mainstream game culture. Again, he turns the question back on me.

I pull out my phone and rack my brain for indie titles I’ve played recently, hoping to somehow earn his respect in that way a detached air of superiority often demands. Rolando 2. Mr AahH!! World of Goo, I list. He repeats each game title after me with a quick nod, an acknowledgment that he’s played each one thoroughly. For a man who supposedly only plays Nobi Nobi Boy, he’s bang up to date.

A little annoyed by this crass one-upmanship I say: Street Fighter IV.

Ah! Street Fighter IV?!” He looks surprised at my changing the rules of the game and ceasing to kowtow to his anti-blockbuster sensibility. We catch each others’ eye and hold the stare for a second. In that moment I see, somewhere under the facade, the chubby 12-year-old Famicom nerd.

He knows that I know. And his face crinkles into the broadest smile of the day.


Related Jobs

Turbine Inc.
Turbine Inc. — Needham, Massachusetts, United States
[04.23.14]

Director, Analytics Platform Development
Linden Lab
Linden Lab — San Francisco, California, United States
[04.23.14]

Sr. Front-end Web Developer
Linden Lab
Linden Lab — San Francisco, California, United States
[04.23.14]

Sr. Software Engineer, Back-end
2K
2K — Novato, California, United States
[04.23.14]

Lead Mission Designer










Comments


Tom Newman
profile image
Let this guy design whatever he wants! I don't think most playgrounds have "designers", so it's an interesting current project, and I'm sure he'll come back to the games industry. Knowing a lot of very creative people, I know that creativity and ideas come in waves. I'm sure he'll have a change of heart the day he wakes up with an idea for the next great unique title.

Allen Seitz
profile image
The intro for this article shocked me. I had to read it twice. Was he really sitting in an abandoned house with no heat playing with a coat hanger? That is so weird. I think I disagree with Mr. Dinehart, this article *does* play up his weirdness myth. Most interviews are Q&A, but this interview was like "So I met Mr. Takahashi, and let me tell you what happened." But I'll definitely believe that he's a nice guy and normal in some way.



I'll answer his question: a good playground is attractive. This kids are going to have fun doing whatever they want, especially dangerous or unintended things. So you might as well build it to be attractive for the city and for the parents watching (horrified) from the perimeter. Plus a little common sense for safety. The kids are definitely going to let go of the swings and fly through the air. Make sure they land on a grassy field, not on pavement or a see-saw.

Chuan Lim
profile image
Emphasize "play" .., de-emphasize "ground" .., make "play play" !



Do we need much of 'ground' in playground? Suppose much of it is about imaginary space anyway -- though you wouldn't want to fall too far onto actual hurt. How about no 'ground', where the kids can build their own ground plane out of oversized & waterproof, soft moulded Tetris or gymnastic blocks? +Re-purpose +Re-imagine seems to be important regarding play.



To mind, one of the most generous things about playgrounds for children are that they're about the only spaces spatially different to the world of 'adult sized' things with our inherently grid-like mindset of parallel & perpendicular shapes. As we get older our brains also get very good at 'closing down' perception of the environment around us with a kind of developed reliance on 'preconceptions' augmenting our experience of the world. So to encourage a mindful grappling with odd shapes, protrusions, and attempt to invert the "30/70" theory of visual regurgitation could be the act of a benevolent designer ..?





-- Chuan

Ed Alexander
profile image
Variety. Variety and openness are the two main spices of a playground.



I remember very vividly the playground at my 4th grade Elementary School. There was a tire swing. A line of normal swings. Small metal structure that led its way up to 2 slides, one a straight metal slide and another a curvy plastic slide in addition to a vertical metal pole reminiscent of a fireman's pole. Monkey bars. A zipline bar. That spherical skeleton of metal bars (never did figure out what they were called...). Teeter totters. Balance beams. 4 Square and Wall Ball areas. 2 Tetherballs. A strip of grass on one end for throwing frisbees or playing soccer. A small basketball court.



There was a lot of variety in things to do. If I ever got tired of playing tetherball, I could go play wall ball. Or monkey around on the monkey bars. The tire swing was always fun, but there were always jerks who would spin it around too fast and wouldn't stop when you wanted them to... I remember kids getting sick from spinning around too much. And the zipline bar was a hit, always had someone at it.



I think the ideal playground would be to just design play areas where there aren't victory or loss conditions, yet goals that the children make themselves and accomplish. Remember the "Don't step on the sawdust because it's hot lava" game? I guess that does lend itself to Mr. Parkin's notation about playgrounds, things were often close enough you could literally jump from one thing to the next. As seen in the Sawdust = Lava game.



Alas, I can't help but sympathize with the guy. I feel I see and understand everything that has driven him into this depression, if you could call it that. The Famicom/Super Famicom was my golden era of gaming, heck, my SNES is right next to my PS3 as it was right next to my PS2 as it was right next to my PS1. It's always been at least an RF plugin away from playable. And I still do to this day.



The corporatization of the industry is as beneficial as it is harmful to the industry, I feel. On one hand, look at how big the industry has become and how far our medium of entertainment has progressed. On the other hand, look at how constrained it is by the ideology and endless chasing of profit.



I hope we see that fabled Renaissance soon. With the wider accessibility of games, more platforms to play them on and the emergence of a bigger, more populated indie scene... Maybe we won't have a Renaissance, but will find room in today's state for a bigger acceptance of indie games that will see a greater return back to what Takahashi-san wants: that youthful, innocent fun.

Bo Banducci
profile image
Mr. Parkin,



I just want to say what an awesome article this was. You gave us a great picture of him. I thought your candidacy was, for the most part, very fair. The subject of the article too... what a cool thing to write about. Thanks a lot. I hope you get more assignments like this.

Patrick Dugan
profile image
I'm with Stephen, particular the ants and anteater metaphor. I'm not sure if agents are the answer, I'm picturing Ari Gold, but maybe that's a stereotype. Personally I like talking to people and fend for myself in terms of negotiation, for better for for worse, but some of the most talented folks don't have a knack for it and get exploited.


none
 
Comment: