Gamasutra: The Art & Business of Making Gamesspacer
Postmortem: Crocodile Entertainment's Zack Zero
View All     RSS
August 29, 2014
arrowPress Releases
August 29, 2014
PR Newswire
View All





If you enjoy reading this site, you might also want to check out these UBM Tech sites:


 
Postmortem: Crocodile Entertainment's Zack Zero

July 3, 2012 Article Start Page 1 of 4 Next
 

[What happens when an indie team's ambition spirals out of control but the game doesn't connect with an audience at the end of the project? In this candid postmortem of Spanish-developed PlayStation 3 downloadable platform title Zack Zero, two developers who started with a small idea that grew and grew share their experiences.]

We started working on Zack Zero in early 2007. At first it was just a two-man team (Carlos Abril and Alberto Moreno, a.k.a. "Grihan"), although in late 2007 Carlos' brother, Nacho Abril, joined the project.

Our initial plan was to make a game with the structure of Carlos' first commercial game, produced over 20 years ago in the 8-bit era (called Phantis in Spain and Game Over II in other countries).

The idea was to make a platform game with 3D graphics but a 2D game structure. Something simple that would take a couple of years to develop for PC and thus have an initial team, structure, engines, tools, procedures, and an introduction for developing our second game for consoles, a world that was foreign and unknown to us.

However, we ended up making our first game for PlayStation 3, which took three more years to develop than what we had initially planned.

What Went Right

1. Use of Our Own Tools and Technology

It's not quite clear to us what would have happened if we had founded Crocodile two or three years later than we actually did. Maybe with the affordable tools and game engines available between 2009 and 2010, we wouldn't have had to build our own engine and tools, spending all the development time to create only the game.

But at the time we started the company, there were no cheap and accessible game engines for small studios, so we started designing our own. Nonetheless, building our own technology did give us the chance to access a grant.


Crocodile Entertainment's model editor (Click for large image)

Crocodile Entertainment's first year was practically dedicated to building all the tools and technology needed for the project. While we were looking into game prototypes, we were also creating the necessary tools to make the art and design tasks easier and independent from programmers.

The first preliminary versions of the engine exported too much information from the 3D software, but slowly we were able to improve our tools making almost everything editable in real time: moving and scaling objects in game levels, delaying and establishing offset parameters for animated objects, particle systems, shaders and materials, etc. Also, all enemy mapping and enemy generators could be placed in-game, controlling the enemy flow, and with the help of Lua scripting, a complete level could be set in real time.

2. A Good Distributed Pipeline

Not having offices has always been a problem while developing the game, although it did make us improve our pipeline, looking constantly for better ways to manage communication and task organization.

Only three programmers have worked on Zack Zero, all of whom were partners in the company: Carlos and Nacho Abril, studio co-founders, and Diego Garcés, who helped us with the enemy AI.

The biggest communication and organization challenge was amongst the art team. During the main production year, the team had two concept artists, one animator and two 3D artists, while some assets were outsourced. Without a dedicated producer and with no offices to resolve any doubts that could arise, it made us work harder in the description and design of the graphic assets we had to create, since we tried to meet only once a month. Since some team members lived far away, we didn't want to waste precious time traveling and attending too many meetings; that's why we defined each month's tasks in detail in each meeting.

This was possible largely due to the work of the concept artists, since they had to help us visualize all the environments, characters, props, etc. For every game asset, however small it could be, we had to work with concept artists to find the appeal we wanted.

The goal was to give 3D artists and animators enough information about what to do and how to do it before returning home; this way we would avoid daily task revision and tedious telephone, instant messenger, or Skype explanations. This was more difficult with animation tasks, especially with character animations that have direct impact on gameplay. In these cases trial and error play a major role, as do good communications between the programmer and the animator -- something Alberto had to personally supervise every day.

When we started the project, the software we used for task management was MS Project, using email to communicate tasks to the people scattered in different places. That did not work. Communication is crucial.

Later, we made a macro of the list of tasks, organized by user and priority, to upload to the wiki, with colors and comments to improve visibility. Wrong. We got neither feedback nor comments. We did have regular staff meetings with the task lists and work layout, but on a day-to-day basis it was impossible because of the overlap.

Later, we began using Google Docs. Things improved communication-wise, but soon visibility was lost and the document became impossible to read, despite being organized into different sections.

We then turned to Basecamp, but eventually switched to Teamwork (we changed because Basecamp worked terribly on iPad, and at the end of the day it is good to review the check list, make comments, prioritize and do all those things sitting comfortably in a chair). It really is much more productive, more participatory and does not require a dedicated producer.

Each person could put in their own tasks, everyone saw everything and could make comments, view them and reply, so people could see the changes and feel more involved. When you finish a task or make a change, it appears in the general list of changes sorted by date, so arriving early in the morning you could see what people had done, comment, see the result and see if anyone needed anything. And the people from Teamwork were very friendly and quickly included some features we suggested in the product: for example, that in the task list, the little icon to include a comment for each task is shown in green if there any new comments that you had not read. This is very useful for reviewing the list in the morning or late in the day.


Article Start Page 1 of 4 Next

Related Jobs

Mixamo
Mixamo — San Francisco, California, United States
[08.28.14]

Animation Outsource Manager
Cloud Imperium Games
Cloud Imperium Games — SANTA MONICA, California, United States
[08.27.14]

Senior Producer
Yoh
Yoh — Vancouver, British Columbia, Canada
[08.27.14]

Rendering Engineer Job
Yoh
Yoh — Vancouver, British Columbia, Canada
[08.27.14]

Multiplayer Designer Job






Comments


Jane Castle
profile image
Great article. I agree that a bit more polish in the final stages would have gotten this game more favorable reviews.

Are you planning on releasing for the PC, Mac and\or Linux?

Alberto Moreno
profile image
Hi Jane, thanks. Yes, we're working in an improved PC version, to release this autumn. We'd like to see Zack Zero in many platforms, so we'll probably release both Mac and Linux versions too. But our development power is very short, so we have to go ahead little by little.

Jane Castle
profile image
On another note, I realize you can't publish exact sales figures, but have the sales been decent enough for you to make future titles?

Alberto Moreno
profile image
Hi Jane,
Unfortunately, not so decent. But I hope that releasing Zack Zero for more platforms will give us enough to develop new games and pay the bills. For sure we'll keep developing games, but we'll have to adapt the size of the new projects.

Jane Castle
profile image
I hope that you continue to make games. Zack Zero looks great. My feeling is that because of such a small team you "ripped off more than you could chew". So when I played the game some things were not as polished as they could have been (well the early version, I played)

Just the same the game was still fun to play and looks great. I think porting it to the PC will get you a wider audience. Perhaps next time also lead the release with the PC. You get to the market much more quickly and can start recouping some money.

Also next time perhaps make some YouTube videos Ala Wolfire Games as the game is being made to show the progress to the community. This makes people talk about your game and gets you awareness.

Eduard Ruzga
profile image
Part of managing team remotely, without having the office is very interesting to me.
Do you mean teamworkpm.net as solution you guys choose in the end?
I with the team in same situation try to use Trello, facebook group and google docs but all have their limitations...

Carlos Abril
profile image
Hi Eduard,
Yes, teamworkpm is the final solution we used. I think it solves properly the main issues: task distribution, comments and discussions, etc. I have tried others and this is the one I liked more. I haven’t tried all so it can be anything better. If you want to analyze the project, there are things that I miss from software like MSProject or OmniPlan like resource leveling, view estimate dates, planning, … I see it as another way of producing where the team members are responsible to add their tasks, you can see what has been changed or updated, comment, ask for something that you need, etc. Some kind of ‘distributed producing’. It has its benefits and its disadvantages but I think it is mainly the only way for a small and distributed team with no dedicated producer.
Hope this helps.

Eloy Ribera
profile image
Very interesting post-mortem indeed. Given the heavy investment you did for an indie title, a multi-platform release is a must. I'm sure that releasing the game in other platforms such as PC will help in recouping the investment.

It's very difficult to rise funds for a mid/high level title here in Spain, as spanish investors are not investing anything in the video games industry and the ones that are investing, they are investing in the wrong companies and/or investing too few to achieve an outstanding success story.

As always, spanish developers are very talented (such as the Zack Zero team), and the big problem is the lack of financial backing and bureaucratic pitfalls.

Alberto Moreno
profile image
Thanks Eloy! As said before, we'll like to launch the game for more platforms. Now working on the PC version, soon we'll show some stuff :)


none
 
Comment: