It's free to join Gamasutra!|Have a question? Want to know who runs this site? Here you go.|Targeting the game development market with your product or service? Get info on advertising here.||For altering your contact information or changing email subscription preferences.
Registered members can log in here.Back to the home page.

Search articles, jobs, buyers guide, and more.

Gamasutra
October 10 2008

Next-Gen Audio Square-Off: PlayStation 3 vs. Xbox 360

arrowrightPage 1
arrowrightPage 2
arrowrightPage 3
arrowrightPage 4
arrowrightPage 5


Printer Friendly Version



Sign up for the Gamasutra Daily Newsletter!

Namco Networks America Inc. : Flash Games Engineer [11.21.08]
War Drum Studios, LLC : Network Game Programmer [11.21.08]
First Act Interactive : Project Lead Software Engineer [11.21.08]
Sony Computer Entertainment America : Senior Manager of Game System Engineering [11.21.08]
Cryptic Studios, Inc. : Lead Game Master Support Representative [11.21.08]
Sparkplay Media : QA Manager [11.21.08]
Cryptic Studios, Inc. : User Interface Designer [11.21.08]
Treyarch / Activision : Technical Director [11.21.08]
Ignition Entertainment : Motion Director [11.21.08]
Ignition Entertainment : Producer [11.21.08]
Sony Pictures Entertainment : Software Engineer / Lua Scripter [11.20.08]
Sony Computer Entertainment America : SR. TECHNICAL PROJECT MANAGER [11.20.08]
Edge of Reality : Project Manager [11.20.08]
Stealth Startup : 3d Graphics Programmer - Virtual Worlds [11.20.08]
Carbine : User Interface/2D Artist [11.20.08]

View All    Post A Job

Post Resume


Upcoming Events:
DIG London Game Conference
London, Canada
11.27.08

5th Australasian Conference on Interactive Entertainment
Brisbane, Australia
12.03.08

IEEE Symposium on Computational Intelligence and Games
Perth, Australia
12.15.08

2K Bot Prize
Perth, Australia
12.15.08

The 6th Annual Mobile Games Forum 2009
London, United Kingdom
01.21.09

Submit Event

View All


Next-Gen Audio Square-Off: PlayStation 3 vs. Xbox 360

(Page 1/5)
Next arrow


Next-generation consoles push more than polygons and deliver more than seamless online integration; they also deliver an unrivaled audio experience to gamers, which can both subtly and obviously increase the quality of the overall gameplay experience immensely.

We're here to crack open the boxes that play these games and take a look under the hood. A lot of speculation has been flying around about just what the heavyweight current generation consoles are capable of. Let us raise the curtain. I managed to hook up with Gene Semel, audio director of Sony Computer Entertainment America, and Brian Schmidt, head of the Xbox audio team, and they gave us the lowdown.

This is followed by discussions with the audio staff on two major titles for the systems: Uncharted: Drake's Fortune on PlayStation 3, and Halo 3 on the Xbox 360.

Xbox 360

What exactly does the internal team at Microsoft do for Xbox, apart from support its developers?

Brian Schmidt: There are multiple teams at work here. You probably have the most face to face contact with XNA's XDC "Xbox Developer Connection" group. Their job is to make sure that people get the best out of Xbox 360 through support, help, samples and so on. They are the group that puts on Gamefest, man the developer support aliases, scour the newsgroups, write whitepapers, etc. and provide front-line pro-active and re-active support for game developers.

A second group is XNA PGP (Professional Game Platform). That is my group. We write the code, libraries and tools that ship in the Xbox XDK and DirectX SDK. So we are the authors of XAudio, XAudio 2, XACT, XMP and are largely responsible for the overall architecture of the system. We're constantly working behind the scenes, adding features and improving efficiency.

We also look at the long-term picture of what tools and technologies we need to be working on for the future. The tools and technologies we provide are used by every Xbox 360 game that ships, allowing game developers to take full advantage of the system in an easy and efficient way. This has a huge impact on the final games that make it into customer's hands.

Of course there are account managers, Game Qualification (Certification), peripheral developers, silicon developers... Far too many to list, actually. But we're all dedicated to making sure that game developer can the most out of our platforms in the most efficient way.

We in PGP work extremely closely with all these groups and often the line between us is a blurry one. I should say that pretty much everyone on the PGP audio team is an active musician, too.

How much were you involved with the Xbox 360's audio hardware design?

BS: I was pretty much responsible for the overall audio system architecture, though of course many others were involved as well. That includes XMA, XAudio, XACT and how the pieces fit together. XMA was an interesting collaboration across a few groups at Microsoft. One of our silicon designers was working on Xbox silicon and thought we could put WMA decoding in hardware.

After some discussions it became clear that with a few modifications we could provide many more voices and take care of some specific gaming scenarios that WMA didn't address, like seamless looping by tweaking things here and there a bit. So we worked with the WMA team on those tweaks and XMA hardware was born.

How much has the industry changed in terms of manpower and budget compared to the previous generation?

BS: Teams, manpower and budget have followed the sheer increase in the size of projects. That's one of the reasons for our investments in high-level technologies such as XACT, that help streamline the process and workflow for creating next generation audio content.

How easy would it be for someone to get hold of an Xbox test or dev kit and train for audio integration using XACT? Are development licenses difficult to get, or can one borrow a 360 for educational purposes?

BS: We ship the exact same XACT for Windows as we do for Xbox 360, so you can easily get XACT for DirectX and run that. Everything you learn will be applicable to Xbox 360. If you really want to run on an Xbox 360, the easiest way is to download XNA Game Studio 2.0. That will let you run your own code on Xbox 360, provided you join the XNA Creators Club. That's the easiest and cheapest way to have direct hands on experience on an Xbox 360.

If you are a more serious audio developer, you can join the Xbox 360 Registered Content Creator Program. This is a program for industry professionals who are already working on an Xbox 360 title that lets you download the actual Xbox 360 XDK and also lets you purchase/license an Xbox 360 Developer Kit.


(Page 1/5)
Next arrow


Comments


tom newman 10 Oct 2008 at 10:27 am PST
Great article! The problem is that great sounding audio is not even scratching the surface on what can be done. While we have seen tremendous advancements in gameplay and graphics, sound design IMO is unfortunately lagging behind (with the obvious exception of music based games).

Anonymous 10 Oct 2008 at 11:14 pm PST
This interview is a little wobbly when it comes to the title of the article.. but it looks like the PS3 wins.. I think.

Vincent Percevault 13 Oct 2008 at 1:57 pm PST
Thank you Alexander for all these shared informations and experiences !

Matthew Grimm 27 Oct 2008 at 9:46 am PST
I'd like to see a multiplatform game analysis. What were the differences in development and quality for a game like Bioshock?

Wylie Garvin 30 Oct 2008 at 11:22 am PST
I'd just like to point out that the claim that Mass Effect fits on a single dvd-9 is probably misleading. Each disc contained only one language (probably because the game had so much recorded dialogue.. I remember counting over 70 voice actors in the credits, and some of them probably had *hours* of dialogue).

I accidentally bought the French version of Mass Effect 360 from a store in Montreal. It had only French on the disc. Its packaging looks almost exactly like the English version, which I later bought, which only has English on the disc. Every other North American game I own for the Xbox 360 has like 5 languages on the disc (typically English, French, German, Italian and Spanish).







join | contact us | advertise | write | my profile
news | features | contract work | jobs | resumes | education | product guide | store