Gamasutra: The Art & Business of Making Gamesspacer





If you enjoy reading this site, you might also want to check out these UBM TechWeb sites:


UK Government reveals tax breaks for video game industry
UK Government reveals tax breaks for video game industry

March 21, 2012 | By Mike Rose
Comments
    18 comments
More: Console/PC, Business/Marketing



advertisement
The UK Government today announced that it intends to introduce tax relief for the UK video games industry, as it aims to make Britain "Europe's technology centre."

The Labour Government had previously said that it would introduce a Games Tax Relief back in March 2010 -- however, the coalition Government then dropped the initiative in June 2010.

UK trade group TIGA suggested soon afterwards that if the Government did not support tax relief for the video games industry, then it may lead to a 24 percent headcount drop over the next five years. It then proposed new tax break measures earlier this year that it said would support the growth of local developers and publishers.

Dr Richard Wilson, CEO of TIGA, called the move a "brilliant decision" and "a decisive victory" for the video games industry.

“Tax relief for the video games sector will increase employment, innovation and investment in the UK video games industry," he continued. "Our research shows that Games Tax Relief should generate and safeguard: 4,661 direct and indirect jobs; £188 million ($297.9 million) in investment expenditure by studios; increase the games development sector’s contribution to UK GDP by £283 million ($448.4 million); generate £172 million ($272.6 million) in new and protected tax receipts to HM Treasury, and could cost just £96 million ($152.1 million) over five years."

Numerous high-profile names in the games industry expressed their delight at the news, including executives from Rebellion, Jagex, Denki, Bossa Studios, Thumbstar Games, Blitz Games Studios, Crytek, nDreams, Relentless and Double Eleven.

Colin Anderson, MD at Denki, said that the proposed tax relief will "stimulate much needed investment and innovation" in the UK video games industry, while Crytek MD Karl Hilton said the move will "promote the creation of high skilled jobs, enhance investment and stimulate an export focussed industry."


Top Stories





Comments


David Pierre
profile image
Aww, I wanted you guys to all move to America so you'd open up more jobs! ...But then again, that'd probably lead even more of your talented workers to move here as well, and it'd become even HARDER to find one.

I guess it's a good thing for all of us then!

Maciej Bacal
profile image
"Numerous high-profile names in the games industry expressed their delight at the news, including executives from Rebellion, Jagex, Denki, Bossa Studios, Thumbstar Games, Blitz Games Studios, Crytek, nDreams, Relentless and Double Eleven."

Imagine that, companies are happy if you give them money.

I can TOTALY see this change will allow gaming companies stationed in UK to take bold risks. Companies will now enter an enlightened era of innovation! New and exciting gameplay, no more quick cash-in DLCs and sequels! No more crunching and better work hours!

What a laugh. UK 2012, "supporting incompetence and proud of it".

Bruno Patatas
profile image
Do you realize you are on a website for professionals of the industry, and not a forum plagued by fanboys and trolls?

Maciej Bacal
profile image
So let's all be subjective then? Don't you think that it's a deeper issue of the gaming industry in general if large companies need to be flat out given money?

This tax break means that if a gaming company makes poor decisions and releases products that don't sell, then it's fine because they'll make money anyway. It's unhealthy and isn't going to fix anything in the long run unless there are actual changes and not more market oversaturation with second grade AAA titles.

Bruno Patatas
profile image
They are not being given money! They are having tax cuts (very different from getting funding), which is great for the games and animation industry here.

Your reply "This tax break means that if a gaming company makes poor decisions and releases products that don't sell, then it's fine because they'll make money anyway." is flawed because we are talking about tax cuts. In the end, this are great news for for smaller companies like Denki.

Maciej Bacal
profile image
If this is so obviously good, could you be more specific, rather than saying, "you're wrong, it's good", without going, gaming companies have it easier. Because to me, this just means that companies that are struggling to make a profit on the highly competetive entertaiment market are being treated differently from others right now, whether it's funding, which i know it isn't, or taxes, they're getting, or not losing as much, money.

There are companies that struggle and cry for tax breaks "or else", but most companies, this includes independant teams, don't, they're doing just fine.

I understand that you fancy yourself a game proffessional and that to anybody having it "easier" means "better", but this is a bigger issue. What's going to change? If a company can't support itself then giving it tax breaks is harmful to everybody.

David Pierre
profile image
I don't know a lot about economy but I do know what extra money would do for me. Relieve stress. This is less about the state of games and more about the state of those who are making them. The less money you have, the more important every single action is. So of course, when tax breaks are zero, your desire to take risks is much smaller. A tax break means more money retained. For any company, big OR small, more money in hand is always a good thing. Larger ones can afford to hire/retain more talent as well as take more calculated risks. Smaller ones will feel less burdened financially in terms of staying afloat.

Also, don't take silence as 'doing fine'. The 'few' that you see complaining are the ones who do it loud enough. There are probably many others doing it silently or probably solving the issue simply by relocating elsewhere. It just wouldn't be feasible to list them all.

Maciej Bacal
profile image
That's my point, though. I understand that it's tax breaks help the industry grow, that young people will have easier time finding a job and that new studios will have easier time developing games. That's great. But to me, these tax breaks are supporting companies that do their buissness poorly. If a company is poorly managed and doesn't bring apropriate profits then it shouldn't be artificialy kept afloat.

More jobs is great and i never wish upon anybody to be fired, but i also sincerely daubt anybody wants to work in a company that's being poorly managed.

Bruno Patatas
profile image
Ok, where should I start?

Should I say first that we are in the middle of a global economic crisis and any help is good?
Every company struggles and needs to adapt. From the big guys like EA to the smaller ones. Smaller companies (more willing to risk on the creative side), can use the extra amount of money spared from the taxes to invest in other products. Animation companies such as Aardman that were thinking on moving some production to Canada, now they already said they will stay in UK.

In the end, if you're not making good products and not being able to sell them, it's not the taxes cut that will save you.

Tax breaks were one of the reasons with the games industry in Canada is so strong right now. Go tell Ubisoft and Square-Enix that they do their business poorly...

james sadler
profile image
Its not about running a company poorly. The UK is a heavily taxed country which prevents some companies and talented employees from wishing to stay, or even start there. Giving tax breaks means they are able to setup shop and run "easier." It has nothing to do with how a company is run. It doesn't say that they're only giving tax breaks to companies that have lost so much money or anything like that. The UK wants to help raise their countries technological front. If you want to say that anyone has run things wrong I'd point first to the government who has made it undesirable to setup or keep a studio in the country. This is just trying to help that.

Jamie Mann
profile image
@Maciej:
The main thing this does is to level the playing field for UK game companies - similar tax schemes already exist in Canada and France and there has been something of a brain-drain effect on companies in the UK.

Think of it as being more about retaining talent (and the money which goes with it - game and movie companies can generate significant amounts of taxable revenue with relatively few employees) for the country, rather than a support system for failing companies. And the reduction in costs means that there's likely to be at least a bit more experimentation and innovation...

Maciej Bacal
profile image
Sounds reasonable, thanks for the replies.

James Coote
profile image
Where do I sign up? :)

I hope it sticks. One of the complaints from many businesses in the UK (not just in games) is that the government keeps changing the law, making it hard to plan long term based on such schemes

Craig Page
profile image
Tax breaks are nice, but you lose your advantage when every other country offers the same or better tax breaks too. The government should take their incentives to the next level: exempt the industry from child labor laws. Imagine all of the jobs that would be created if the best and brightest school children were working 80 hours a week on the next big console game and countless other handheld games.

Darcy Nelson
profile image
I can't tell if you're joking or not.

Tomas Majernik
profile image
He better be joking.

J Spartan
profile image
It is great news for the few remaining uk games developers/publishers. It's about trying to keep your technical talent as much as helping with the financial side of things. In particular most of the other top tier game developing countries give tax breaks, and for years uk based companies have struggled to keep the local uk production base going in this uneven playing field.

Possibly it may be too late already to make a huge impact as many of the bigger uk companies have already moved to Canada or the States, or atleast sold themselves to bigger companies that operate from those countries. We shall see, but certainly if i was looking to start up a studio in the uk, this would be the kind of news that could help in that decision. I just hope it isn't too late to breath much needed life into the uk games industry, which can be a very creative and technicaly compitent one.

Jim Partridge
profile image
Once upon a time, back in the 1980's the UK had a booming games industry. Weird and wonderful titles like Jet Set Willy, Manic Miner, Hover Bover were pumped out for open platforms like the sinclair and C64 etc..

Games were sold on an unlocked format (cassette) and these small development houses were able to grind out a small profit while having complete creative freedom.

As the console market came of age, the licensing costs and pre-requisites for of simply being able to release a game onto a locked down platform became prohibitively expensive. This pushed control of the gaming market (outside of the PC) into the hands of several large orgnanisations (PSN, EA, Activision etc..) and slowley eroded the innovation of those early years.

While these tax breaks make it more appealing to create a games development house in the UK, the hugely prohibitive costs of the console market still make it doubtful that independent start ups in the UK will be able to release content to anything other than the PC platform without selling out / partnering to the big publishing firms and thus stifling innovation once again.

The PC platform is exploding with many new innovative indie titles at the moment which is fantastic but not the real win that the UK games industry is looking for as the big money is not in PC indie titles but with the mainstream console market.

That is until someone releases an Indie console based on the Raspberry Pi... :P


none
 
Comment: