Gamasutra: The Art & Business of Making Gamesspacer
View All     RSS
October 31, 2014
arrowPress Releases
October 31, 2014
PR Newswire
View All





If you enjoy reading this site, you might also want to check out these UBM Tech sites:


The wonderful depravity of Frictional Games' Soma Exclusive
October 21, 2013 | By Leigh Alexander

October 21, 2013 | By Leigh Alexander
Comments
    5 comments
More: Design, Exclusive, Video



The trailer for Frictional Games' upcoming Soma seems to bear a signature: The coupling of the mechanical with the biological, and a distinct sense of forboding. The company's focused on horror games since its Penumbra titles, but following two well-liked Amnesia titles, Soma feels like it rounds out an aesthetic.

Notably Frictional has long tried to make games that get their appeal from story and environment, not combat mechanics. The first Amnesia game, The Dark Descent, eschewed combat in favor of a "sanity" system -- that the player would suffer from being too close to monsters or even looking at them for too long forced them to hide, lighting candles all the while to keep the fearful darkness at bay.

The recently released Amnesia: A Machine for Pigs, developed by Dear Esther house Thechineseroom, also had no combat, signaling the player to be cautious with flickering electric lights. Frictional creative director Thomas Grip tells Gamasutra that while creating intense gameplay is exponentionally more difficult when you can't rely on combat as a "crutch," removing combat from its games was necessary -- the team just wasn't good at designing it.

Frightening without fighting

At the time Frictional was preparing its first games, the Condemned series hit the scene, excelling in frightening melee. With its small team and limited resources, the team knew it couldn't come close, and decided to think about what else they could do instead. Since then, frightening without fighting has been something of a company ethos.

Though the team's often been tempted to use combat sequences to solve design problems ("it's so alluring!"), Frictional has since stuck to its guns -- rather, stuck to no guns, nor overuse of any other objects that can be weaponized. Working in the horror space, this is an even broader challenge than one might expect. Even though there are no "weapons" in The Exorcist, there's still holy water to throw.

"A poisonous attitude for some games is you always want to take the easy route," Grip says. "You feel you need to have a 'core,' -- 'oh, this is the game!'... like, [you feel you need to] know everything there is to know about a game, and then just multiply it by a hundred. What we do instead is make every area almost like a game in itself. We script a lot, and there's tons of logic that goes into it. There's enough interactive stuff happening that it creates dynamic gameplay.

"Just because it's scripted doesn't mean we're making the player follow an exact route," he continues. Rather than design a "perfect" experience a player is expected to have, there should be flexibility -- a number of environmental possibilities. It's tough to get right, but for Grip, worthwhile.

Avoiding "designing by committee"

Despite such a tight internal philosophy, Frictional gave the follow-up to its standout Amnesia property to an external studio. It was the company's first time working in that capacity. As Dear Esther was also an atmospheric, environment-led game with a conscientiously-unconventional attitude to "gameplay," developer Thechineseroom was a good fit.

Frictional had also already begun work on Soma, and worried it would take a long time, creating a significant gap between the cult success of Amnesia: The Dark Descent and the company's next game. Wanting to keep momentum up, they thought a spiritual successor to Amnesia would be a good idea.

soma 1.jpg"The biggest challenge for both sides was to avoid 'design by committee,' and let a single vision be responsible for most of the design. We had to let go of giving too much direction," Grip says. For one thing, he hated the name A Machine for Pigs, but thought it was important to let Thechineseroom name their project (the title's grown on Grip over time).

"I liked the final product even though it was pretty dissimilar from the first game," he adds. "If we're going to have them doing it, we have to be aware that it's going to be a very different project in the end, and embrace that. And there are also a lot of very strong similarities in how you play the game, and the thematics, stuff like that."

"I guess we're depraved people"

With Soma, Frictional continues its horror focus almost in spite of itself. "The theme we wanted was 'probing the depths of the mind,'" says Grip. Presently, the trailer shows a brain being stabbed with actual probes. "It felt better having it in a horror environment than in a mystery environment.

"It's not like we consciously try to do the same thing, I guess we're depraved people," he laughs. "There are a lot of slugs and strange naked things coming up from my subconscious."

Although the absence of combat in favor of environmental interaction makes horror scarier by taking the player's sense of physical power away, it seems horror design also seems to serve games without fighting in them: There's still a tension and anxiety about the environment, the sense that an "enemy" exists, and that the stakes are high.

Soma aims to explore players' minds and subvert expectations by manipulating player behavior, Grip says. "Interesting things spring up when you put people in situations that you have to evaluate according to an imaginary mind model," he explains. For a simple example, if players hear frightening noises from one direction and not another, they're liable to explore the apparently-safer route first, and that's information designers can use to create more complex experiences.

"In Amnesia: The Dark Descent we were using this for cheap scares, and the deeper thematics came on at a very late stage," says Grip. "This time, I want to explore how far we can take this kind of thinking. I know it's going to be a bit risky. We couldn't have done it in the past, though, because we hadn't had enough experience with how players react."

The team is hoping for an early 2015 launch for Soma, which will also be the company's first console release, in addition to PC, Mac and Linux. "It's not an immense difference, just a new opportunity," Grip says, of developing for PlayStation 4. "It's like a console PC. There's not some weird Cell processor we have to spend a year learning. I'm not sure how much we can expand our audience, but it's going to be interesting to find out."


Related Jobs

Magic Leap, Inc.
Magic Leap, Inc. — Wellington, New Zealand
[10.30.14]

Level Designer
Grover Gaming
Grover Gaming — Greenville, North Carolina, United States
[10.30.14]

3D Generalist / Artist
Demiurge Studios, Inc.
Demiurge Studios, Inc. — Cambridge, Massachusetts, United States
[10.30.14]

Lead System Designer
DeNA Studios Canada
DeNA Studios Canada — Vancouver, British Columbia, Canada
[10.29.14]

Analytical Game Designer










Comments


Maria Jayne
profile image
I'm bemused why they would release a trailer about a game not due until sometime 2015. Seems way too early to be showing it.

They make really good horror games though, no argument there.

Scott Lavigne
profile image
I'm willing to bet it's meant to be for reassurance since some people weren't so happy with The Chinese Room's A Machine For Pigs.

E McNeill
profile image
"There are a lot of slugs and strange naked things coming up from my subconscious."

I expect this to be implemented literally in their next game.

Kevin Fishburne
profile image
I think it's interesting that combat was completely removed from the games, but the idea of minimizing combat in horror games is spot on. Constant fighting with high-powered weapons is IMHO what killed the Resident Evil series.

If you are going to have a horror game with tons of guns they need to be largely ineffective. Think Aliens, for example (the film). At first you're like, "Oh wow, these hard core marines are going to blast the shit out of the aliens" (which is what the marines were thinking initially), then bravado quickly deteriorates into, "Oh God, let's get the hell out of here" when you realize your guns and grenades don't come close to cutting it.

Dave Hoskins
profile image
Duck-shoot games are easier to committee manage than these nightmarish story driven games, and I wish them all the luck. We need more games like this, but please stop making them too scary, as light relief is always needed from time to time.
The heavy breathing doesn't work for me though, because it makes it feel third-person rather actually being the character itself. Strangely, narration works well with FPG, maybe because it's always the story that matters the most.


none
 
Comment: