Gamasutra: The Art & Business of Making Gamesspacer
Kickstarter post-mortem: Legends of Eisenwald
Printer-Friendly VersionPrinter-Friendly Version
View All     RSS
April 16, 2014
arrowPress Releases
April 16, 2014
PR Newswire
View All
View All     Submit Event





If you enjoy reading this site, you might also want to check out these UBM TechWeb sites:


 
Kickstarter post-mortem: Legends of Eisenwald
by Alexander Dergay on 02/08/13 09:05:00 am   Featured Blogs

The following blog post, unless otherwise noted, was written by a member of Gamasutra’s community.
The thoughts and opinions expressed are those of the writer and not Gamasutra or its parent company.

 

[Aterdux Entertainment was the first company from the ex-USSR to successfully raise funds for a computer game project (or maybe for any project) at Kickstarter and we would like to share some thoughts and recommendations that might be useful for others. Click on any graphs for a full-width version.]

Dedicated to our backers at Kickstarter and outside who made our dream of bringing Legends of Eisenwald to completion possible!

This is a long overdue post mortem of our Kickstarter campaign for Legends of Eisenwald. We were the first company from the ex-USSR to successfully raise funds for a computer game project (or maybe for any project) and we would like to share some thoughts and recommendations that might be useful for others.

Now there are a lot of post-mortems from bigger sized projects but few with the goal amounts similar to ours. Anyway, when we started in April of last year there was no such information available and I wish we ran across something like this before our campaign started. In my future posts here I will write how our development and our campaign at Steam Greenlight is going. More details are available at our site.

The Goal

We chose a minimal amount of $50000 – we saw that a lower amount wouldn't have allowed us to finish our game. We saw a lot of successful campaigns but we also saw many unsuccessful ones.

As much as we wanted to follow an example of The Banner Saga or Wasteland 2, we were fully aware that for a little known team like ours we had to be more realistic and humble. FTL seemed like a better example for us but they had a demo version. We didn’t. We were hoping for the best but we were prepared for any outcome.

Campaign Duration

Based on statistics we decided to do 30 days campaign. According to then existing Kickstarter statistics we saw that the success rate of projects 30 days or shorter was 44%, while for maximum length projects (back then it was 90 days, currently it’s shortened to 60) success rate is 24%.

The current Kickstarter statistics show that overall, in games success rate is 34%. Looking at all this, for little known projects like ours longer length might still be beneficial. We only got good press coverage towards the end of our campaign – we reached our goal with over 9 days left.

So, making it longer would have been definitely beneficial, but probably still not longer than 40-45 days. Running our campaign took us a lot of time and effort and I doubt that we could have survived doing it two full months. 

Start of the campaign and some mistakes

We knew PR was important. We still managed to underestimate how important it was.

Mistake #1 There was no information anywhere in the media that we were going to start our campaign on Kickstarter. Our game wasn’t even announced.

Recommendation #1 Send out press release (press packs) about an upcoming campaign some time ahead. Announce your project.

If we had to do it again, we would announce our game a month or two before, then announce our plans for Kickstarter and then start the campaign itself.

Mistake #2 We started our campaign on Saturday. Weekends are slower than weekdays on Kickstarter because the biggest percentage of Kickstarter backers are from the US and it seems to be a national US tradition to leave somewhere for the weekend )(good tradition, I would say).

When we started our campaign we got to learn it very fast. Also, sending our press releases on the weekends proved to be very inefficient. As later some more experienced people told us, on the weekends editors get a lot of spam so often they don’t look at any of the messages received. For two first days we were pretty much without any press coverage.

Recommendation #2 Start your campaign on a week day.
Personally, we think Monday or Tuesday could be a good day to launch a project.

Mistake #3 We didn’t have enough promotional materials and we had to make a lot of them during our campaign. Also, we had to explain many things how our game worked.

Recommendation #3 Create a lot of promotional materials. Videos seem to be the best for this.

Our first press release went out only on the 4th day of the campaign. It attracted some attention and there were a few articles. This press release was written and translated by us and since it was our first attempt to write something for English speaking audience, it wasn’t very good, unfortunately.

But, it brought several good results: it attracted attention in Germany, pcgameshardware.com wrote an article about our campaign and its Editor in Chief Thilo Bayer became our backer and enthusiastic supporter. Also, the known and respected site rpgcodex.net contacted us and we got our first interview ever! That was very exciting.

We also participated in discussions in this forum which turned to be very productive – in discussions like in this forum or with our backers on Kickstarter it was getting very obvious on what we had to work next. Everyone wanted to see a combat video. That was something we didn’t have and that’s was a mistake described above. It didn’t take us long however to create this video, combat was working in our game already for a long time.

Middle of the campaign

In the beginning days because of the weekends, we had around 50-80 backers per day. On one hand, this is a lot considering absolute lack of coverage. On another hand, this is not enough – with these numbers without any change we wouldn’t have been able to fulfill our goal.

Luckily for us Stoic, the creators of The Banner Saga recommended our game along with others in their campaign update to 20K+ backers they had. The result you can see below in the picture: 345 backers and $7571 on day 7 of the campaign, $3107 and 150 backers on day 8 of the campaign.


Kicktraq Statistics 

We were already working on our combat video, and it was released on the day 8 of our campaign. While it didn’t attract high amount of backers, we received several high amount pledges and after that we reached over $30000 of funding.

Despite some press we got, our press coverage still was rather modest. We ran on pure enthusiasm of  ourselves and of our amazing backers. Many of them were spreading information in forums, in other Kickstarter projects and honestly, we don’t know what would have happened without their help.

Some of our backers in Kickstarter and also on rpgcodex helped us write several more press releases. We sent them away ourselves. Guess what? Here we go again, this time to mistake #4.

Mistake #4 Sending press releases on your own is a mistake in our opinion.

Recommendation #4 Either use professional press release distribution service or let your PR agency do that for you.

One of the backers wrote a very good press release, he was a journalist in the past and while it didn’t have an immediate effect on our press coverage, it made us see what a huge difference it was when press release is written by a professional and when it is written by us.

Recommendation #5

Get a professional help with press releases, especially if English is not your mother tongue!

We decided we need professional help with it. Better later than never. I recalled reading an article on a Russian site about new PR agency for indie game developers. I found the article and contacted that agency - it's called Surprise Attack. I contacted themand we started to work together. And we continue working with them.

Last part of the campaign

Towards the end of the campaign we added a new $35 reward that would include all of our future expansions. We made a mistake of calling it DLC and had to come up with another update to explain what we meant.

Recommendation #5 Whatever you do, communication with backers is a must. Bear in mind, whatever you say is basically a promise. Choose your words carefully.

We hit our Kickstarter goal of $50000 a 10 days before our campaign was over. It happened on May 12 and it was Saturday. We scrambled for an update (we didn’t expect it so soon) and our success press release went out on Mondau. By Wednesday we got some more press coverage. Release of Diablo 3 on that week was a bit unfortunate for us but expected.

And then came great news: on Friday an article came out on Rock Paper Shotgun called We are the Knight: Legends of Eisenwald 

That made a big impact. Despite the fact that Kickstarter statistics shows only $3715 from RPS but it accounts only for direct backers. Many people who don’t follow a link from a site are not counted as a backer from a specific site. We believe RPS accounts at least for $15000 of extra pledges we received, and we are very grateful to them!

Publication on RPS was probably both a result of press release and of some active users from forums on somethignawful.com. The results of this publication you can see in the diagrams above.

In our update we posted several stretch goals and we managed to hit two of them. The last days of campaign were stressful, we slept little and worked on our final update in the midst of discussions of what else we can do.

Post campaign thoughts and statistics

After all fees and dropped backers we received $75047 (the amount on Kickstarter shows $83577, after subtracting $754 from dropped backers it’s actually $82823). Also, we received about $1000 from Paypal and Yandex money pledges after the end of the campaign.

As it turned out, we can’t change our project after our campaign was over so, here comes the next recommendation.

Recommendation #6 In the last day of your campaign think about what you want to be on your project page.

If we could we would place there information about how people can make their pledges after the campaign is over.

Here is our statistics from our Kickstarter page:

Statistics1

Statistics2

 

Some resources:

1. http://kicktraq.com  – very useful site to see statistics and results of your actions.
2. Facebook group Russians on Kickstarter 
3. Popularity of our video
Video plays 

4. Popularity of rewards
Rewards popularity 
No reward - 44 Backers (2% of backers), $2081 pledged (2% of money raised)
$15 Reward - 1429 Backers (52% of backers), $21062 pledged (26% of money raised)
$25 Reward - 284 Backers (10% of backers), $7150 pledged (9% of money raised)

$35 Reward - 693 Backers (25% of backers), $24341 pledged (29% of money raised)
$50 Reward - 108 Backers (4% of backers), $5620 pledged (7% of money raised)
$75 Reward - 91 Backers (3% of backers), $6922 pledged (8% of money raised)

$100 Reward - 53 Backers (2% of backers), $5391 pledged (6% of money raised)
$175 Reward - 12 Backers (< 1% of backers), $2890 pledged (3% of money raised)
$200 Reward - 10 Backers ( < 1% of backers), $2031 pledged (2% of money raised)

There were also 3 rewards of $500 and 2 of $2000.

Thank you for reading until the end :) I hope you find it useful.  


Related Jobs

Treyarch / Activision
Treyarch / Activision — Santa Monica, California, United States
[04.16.14]

Associate Producer - Treyarch
Treyarch / Activision
Treyarch / Activision — Santa Monica, California, United States
[04.16.14]

Production Coordinator (temporary) - Treyarch
Vicarious Visions / Activision
Vicarious Visions / Activision — Albany, New York, United States
[04.16.14]

Software Engineer-Vicarious Visions
Sledgehammer Games / Activision
Sledgehammer Games / Activision — Foster City, California, United States
[04.16.14]

Desktop Support Technician, Temporary - Sledgehammer Games






Comments


Daniel Erickson
profile image
A great scrappy success story. Congrats and thanks for sharing. Good luck!

Alexander Dergay
profile image
Daniel Erickson, thank you! Maybe someone will learn from our mistakes, it's not necessary to always learn on your own ones :)

Jannis Froese
profile image
Thanks for the great article, especially your insights on press releases were totally new to me.

Also thanks for sharing all those graphs. It seems like very few projects share them, and Kickstarter's official numbers are always somewhat unspecific. The only thing I was kind of missing was graph 4b, total amount of money per pledge amount. For example there were less 50$ bakers than 75$ bakers, but the total pledge amount is higher for the 75$ bakers. That's exactly the kind of information that is useful for designing reward levels.

Alexander Dergay
profile image
Jannis Froese, I added this information at the bottom. On Kickstarter it's not a graph, you see this info only when you point with a mouse over it. Thank you for pointing it out! I was going to include this information but forgot.

Abel Bascunana Pons
profile image
I'm grateful for this info Alexander, as we'll go KS in a month and a half. Even we've already done some research, there are really good points here i was unaware of.

The curious thing for me is what you say about combat. How it didn't occur to you to add some footage of the combat in the initial video?

Best luck with your game! =)

Maria Jayne
profile image
I'm wondering if kickstarter activity is less about people going away for the weekend and more the fact that many backers browse the internet during work hours and so that is traditionally Mon-Fri for offices. Come the weekend people would rather play games than browse when they are on their computers.

shayne oneill
profile image
Its more about the news cycle and specifically the deadlines of those organizations. On saturday, your press release wont even get looked at till monday morning at the earliest and a lot can happen during that time.

Matthew Burns
profile image
Great advise for future gaming Kickstarter campaigns.

Karin E Skoog
profile image
Great recommendations regarding press releases and timing. Publicity can make all the difference in success. It seems a lot of indie game devs could benefit from a company specializing in marketing indie games from conception through after completion so developers can focus on creating games as opposed to the time and effort it takes to efficiently market games.

Alexander Dergay
profile image
Abel, our presentation video had some combat, but combat system was raising many questions and there is no place for it in the short pitch of the video. And video shouldn't be very long anyway, so it was a matter of choice.

Maria, there can be definitely many explanation, but the fact is that it's not good to start a campaign on the weekend or shortly before. We unfortunately did :) No need to repeat this mistake.

Karin, publicity is everything. It's not that smart to hope people will find a project on Kickstarter. Without promotion even a very good project is not going to make it.

Thank you for all your comments!

shayne oneill
profile image
Hey Alexander. I think that might have been me that helped rewrite that press release. My grammar is actually attrocious (As I said *ex* journo, lol) but yeah, it was clear you guys needed some help there. Next time I need a belarusian press release I'll be on the phone :P :P

Press releases are actually very important. Journalists are basically both lazy and overworked. They are always going to take the easiest option and i they have to sort through 100 press releases, they'll just skip to the ones that are easiest to read (Put the key points *first*) and easiest to rewrite. So I actually recomend basically writing the article one would like the journalist to write, and just tweaking it enough so its still a press release. Chances are, the journalist will just re-arange some words, put his name on it, and you'll get the article you most wanted. Its cheating but hey.

Alexander Dergay
profile image
Hi Shayne! That was definitely you and that was huge help! Before you explained things to us, we had very little clue and for that we are grateful. Something that I promised will be coming your way upon release :)


none
 
Comment: